News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by paulsingh on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:36PM (#1569173)
Pardon my ignorance, but I don't get it.

Why would you want to hire someone that "sprays" their application across 25+ companies?

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by shazow on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:52PM (#1569231)
The reality of an applicant is that there is extremely little information about a startup and its reputation, and what little there is is almost always identical to every other startup (free food, have an impact, big challenges, blah blah blah).

You only really discover whether it's a good fit or not after you've worked there for months. If you're really lucky, after you've had all the interviews. But really never ever before you've even applied.

During the application process, I'd argue that the employer has the best idea whether the fit would be good or not.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by edanm on Monday August 02, 2010 @06:03PM (#1569256)
This is especially true of YC companies, I suspect. I'm pretty sure all YC-funded startups have great working conditions, and most of them have pretty good ideas and a good chance of making it.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by cyen on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:59PM (#1569245)
What happened to wanting to work on a product you (can) love?
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by shazow on Monday August 02, 2010 @07:02PM (#1569434)
Product changes more frequently than the team or culture.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by nicholasjbs on Monday August 02, 2010 @06:08PM (#1569286)
There are several reasons. For one, most of the best engineers and hackers have jobs already. Even if they're not super happy with their jobs, the prospect of seeking out better places to work, submitting lots of resumes and cover letters, etc, has a high activation energy. The YCommonApp is a convenient way for people to get introduced to a whole bunch of high-quality and exciting places to work in a short amount of time.

Also, since it's a custom application, anyone responding to it will have taken the time to fill it out specifically, which eliminates the standard resume-sprayers on craigslist, et al.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by pg on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:08PM (#1569723)
Why would you turn away someone good because they'd applied to other companies?
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by dschobel on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:26PM (#1569754)
As an employer, wouldn't you demand someone be interested in the specific problems you're trying to solve though? Do kids who want to be part of $generic_sexy_yc_startup last long?

(that's a sincere, non-rhetorical question)

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by pg on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @12:39AM (#1570148)
Sure, but I'd assume they'd decide that in a later phase. Submitting something to YCommonApp is just like going to a mixer where you think interesting companies might be.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by johnrob on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @01:13AM (#1570204)
I was thinking about proposing something like a mixer (after reading these threads today), and now that you've mentioned it - why not have regular mixers for hiring YC companies and interested hackers?
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by pg on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @12:07PM (#1571648)
We had one after http://workatastartup.org
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by paulsingh on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @01:36AM (#1570243)
OK, that's fair... maybe they can decide at a later phase. I guess I take issue with this being presented as a way to "apply to 25+ startups" instead of a more "mixer-like" approach.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by BrandonM on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:34AM (#1570337)
I don't consider myself a kid anymore, but I'd still love to be part of a startup. The opportunity to work with smart individuals in a sensible environment is pretty huge. The potential to learn a lot about what is required in running a startup is another thing. The ability to make a good living while doing something cool is yet another.

I'm one of those people who doesn't particularly care what startup I work for. As long as it's not a spamming site or something else that generally makes the world a worse place, I'd be excited to work there.

If I wanted to solve problems I was interested in, I'd be a Ph.D. student, create a personal project, start my own startup, or get a completely unrelated job while programming in my spare time. Right now (for the next few years, at least) I just want to make some good, reasonably-steady money while providing value in a job that I enjoy. The specific problems I'd be solving have very little bearing on my thought process right now.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @09:22AM (#1570992)
Right now (for the next few years, at least) I just want to make some good, reasonably-steady money while providing value in a job that I enjoy. The specific problems I'd be solving have very little bearing on my thought process right now.

Um, it sounds like you really don't want to work for a startup. And, that's not a bad thing.

Perhaps you've been oversold on the startupian == special forces, genco employee == demoralized grunt attitude that's common on sites like this.

The opportunity to work with smart individuals in a sensible environment is pretty huge.

There is no generic startup, and many startups are far from sensible!

All that said, I'm in week two of my startup, but it's because I have an unbearable, pathological, un-fucking-reasonable need to work for myself.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with steady and sensible, but you're not likely to find it by generically applying to startups.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by BrandonM on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @11:27AM (#1571485)
I realize that there are non-startups I'd enjoy working for, but in general I think that being employee number 10-50 would suit me better. I'd prefer to spend the majority of my time developing new code. I enjoy creating APIs. I would want to be able to execute good ideas (that make it quickly into the end product) myself without a ton of bureaucracy. Sure, there are some companies where these things are true, but I think they are much more likely to be the case in a startup.

And when I say "steady", I don't mean that I need a high-paying job that I needn't be scared of losing for the next several years. I simply mean that I would like a salary with a monthly or bi-weekly paycheck for as long as I happen to be working there. I only meant steady in relation to freelancing or creating my own product.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by aaronbrethorst on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:57PM (#1569817)
I think there are interesting, challenging problems to solve at any and every funded startup (why else would they have been able to receive funding?).

I'm far more interested in working on The Next Big Thing—especially if it's a big challenge—than I am in a specific problem domain. Maybe it's just the way I'm wired; maybe it's a reflection of my skillset.

My guess is that the kind of person who would be attracted to the idea of working at any and all YC-backed startups is the same kind of person who is more interested in tackling big, challenging problems than any particular problem domain. Maybe I'm wrong and just projecting. What do you think?

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by dschobel on Monday August 02, 2010 @11:22PM (#1570000)
It's a subjective question so don't feel bad about projecting. I was coming from the diametrically opposed position where I have a very specific interest and background (robotics) so I couldn't go write web-apps even if the business side ("the next big thing") was extremely compelling.

I was mostly trying to understand how (and if) YC's alpha engineers would happily go work on "the next big thing", largely independent of what that thing was.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by acgourley on Monday August 02, 2010 @11:21PM (#1569996)
I agree that the person should investigate the company a bit more before shotgunning out his or her application. I don't agree the domain matters so much, what matters is something fuzzier. I'm not sure exactly how to define it, but consider that at the 'trenches' level YC funded companies do a lot of the same day-to-day tasks with the same technologies.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by euroclydon on Monday August 02, 2010 @06:48PM (#1569394)
Because it's P.R. for HiveHire. Why does P.G. use Posterous sometimes?
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by pg on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @12:36AM (#1570146)
Actually I didn't tell the 25 startups to use HireHive. The HireHive founders convinced them. It was easy because they're all desperate to hire.

And Posterous I use because I genuinely like it. Before Posterous we never blogged at all, because it seemed like too much trouble.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by euroclydon on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:51AM (#1570741)
Yeah, I didn't think you told them to use it. I've just noticed that the YC community seems to use eachother's products in order to achieve a compounding synergy-type effect, even if it sometime seems a bit odd, like this.

Also, I didn't draw the distinction between your essay site and "blogging." Makes sense now.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by vegashacker on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @01:58PM (#1572036)
I'm pretty sure I remember a Y Combinator Weebly blog. Also there was the Infogami PG blog, but I suppose that was you, not your company.
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by prog123hn on Monday August 02, 2010 @06:05PM (#1569268)
Why do you see Glade advertise Glade PlugIns on prime time television? Because sometimes you turn on the television to watch True Blood and still decide to buy a Glade PlugIn.

This model helps centralize the process for the popular companies, and it gives the less popular ones access to quality candidates. Everyone has a hiring problem.

Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @12:27AM (#1570127)
True blood is on hbo; no commecials
Re:YCommonApp: Apply to 25+ YC-funded startups in under 10 m... by Tichy on Monday August 02, 2010 @06:39PM (#1569372)
Why not?