News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @03:24PM (#1568717)
A thing is what it does. What you label it with isn't anywhere near as important as what it does.

In practice, these "nations" appear to be nothing more than special interest groups. Special interest groups already tend to expand well beyond their original goals in the political arena. That doesn't work because the active leadership takes over and speaks for the public; why these would avoid that, I don't know. So, the solution to too many special interest groups is more special interest groups.

Also, I think he uses "Tea Party" like bogeymen. To the extent the movement involves cutting government down, it will actually increase the scope of agreement within the government by cutting down the number of domains in which there is disagreement. In fact, my personal prescription for where we are right now is for a significant return of power to the states. Some things have to be national-scale policy, but the list is much shorter than you think. We don't need a national-scale health care plan. Many of our states are larger than European countries that manage. State plans already exist. We don't need national agreement on any given social issue. If we weren't centralizing all our power, we wouldn't have to spend so much time arguing what the central policy should be.

The other major problem these sort of idealistic ideas have is that it basically promises everybody that it will bring the world closer to their viewpoint, but that can't actually happen. Right now, for better or worse, our government is more liberal than our population, so if your plan is to push our government yet more liberal by empowering the population, err, well, you might want to rethink that plan.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by Locke1689 on Monday August 02, 2010 @04:45PM (#1569001)
In fact, my personal prescription for where we are right now is for a significant return of power to the states. Some things have to be national-scale policy, but the list is much shorter than you think. We don't need a national-scale health care plan. Many of our states are larger than European countries that manage. State plans already exist. We don't need national agreement on any given social issue. If we weren't centralizing all our power, we wouldn't have to spend so much time arguing what the central policy should be.

I think you actually underestimate the complexities here. The problem isn't number of people -- you're correct, many states are as large as European countries. However, the states don't have nearly as much self-governing power (as granted by the Constitution) as European countries. In things like healthcare, this makes a big difference. For example, one of the biggest benefits to the federal government is that it can temporarily run a budget deficit during hard times. There are innumerable times (including now) when that would be necessary for a large swath of public services. It would require a rather huge change in federal law in order to make this work on the state level. Another problem you would get is massive problems with the full-faith-and-credit clause. All in all, it may be worth considering that, accounting for modern high-speed transportation and intercommunication and trade, strong states may be an antiquated idea.

Right now, for better or worse, our government is more liberal than our population

That's difficult to argue. Notably, consider that one person's vote in Wyoming counts 67 times more than a Californian's in the US Senate and 1.264 times a Californian's in the House of Representatives.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:41PM (#1569667)
"It would require a rather huge change in federal law in order to make this work on the state level."

Yes. I did say "significant return of power to the states", after all.

"All in all, it may be worth considering that, accounting for modern high-speed transportation and intercommunication and trade, strong states may be an antiquated idea."

It is also worth considering the opposite, that in an era of increased administrative efficiency, increased economic efficiency, and increased communication efficiency, that the need for one strong overarching State is diminishing. Everything else is decentralizing as a result of the very forces we cite; why is the State such a special exception?

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by fluidcruft on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:43AM (#1570448)
I don't see any evidence that corporations and capitol are following any pattern of "decentralizing" whatsoever. What do you base that assertion on? Rather the opposite. Multinationals already run roughshod over nations. Stronger international governments are what is needed. Wouldn't more "powerful" States be even cheaper marks for corporate soft power?
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by tomjen3 on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:23PM (#1569141)
For what it is worth Denmark runs a deficit now, and I doubt there is a single state in the US that is anywhere as tiny as Denmark.

Granted the Danish economy is more sound than, say California but still.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by randomtask on Monday August 02, 2010 @07:35PM (#1569522)
The population of Denmark is 5.5 million, which if it were a US state, would make it the 21st largest state.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by Locke1689 on Monday August 02, 2010 @07:47PM (#1569550)
Yeah but that's mostly irrelevant. As I said, the problem isn't size, it's state and federal law.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by aidenn0 on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:39PM (#1569183)
Any entity can run at a budget deficit. There is this new-fangled banking instrument known as a "loan"
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by Locke1689 on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:55PM (#1569239)
Yeah, that's not how it works. I feel like we're talking past each other. The nature of state and federal fiscal policy is complex, but this article covers an introduction to it http://www.ncsl.org/IssuesResearch/BudgetTax/StateBalancedBu.... You'll note that there are ways that states can run deficits in practice but there are a number of restrictions which affect how appropriations work in practice.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by kgermino on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:01PM (#1569576)
However you will also note that budget restrictions are self-imposed by state law or state constitutions, which would likely be rewritten as the states took over more social services.

Another reason that I like the idea of states and local governments handling more services is that it is politically more difficult to waste money on stupid projects. For Example: a road near my house was recently repaved using money from the stimulus. It was in fine shape before and didn't need work done but most people were not upset because the federal government payed for most, if not all, of it. However if my village said that sales taxes would be raised .25% for 6 mos. to pay for the project most of these same people would have immediately decided that repaving the road wasn't worth the cost.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by _pi on Monday August 02, 2010 @03:39PM (#1568764)
Another good point about his strategy is that he derives almost everything from the feel good feeling of "You're on the internet, I'm on the internet You can trust me." This is no different than candidates touting their religious affiliation. We're all on the internet, in fact I don't know a person who isn't, and many of those people that I know don't share my politics, let alone my views on life.

And most importantly the people who are in the Tea Party also use the Internet. Here's the problem with his concept of nations, look at the UN. Look at congress, they are all abstracts of general political distributions. All of the deadlock, ALL the time. Why? Because there's going to always be a pro-coffee and an anti-coffee nation/interest group/campaign. Sean Tevis can't fix human nature with any amount of money.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by asnyder on Monday August 02, 2010 @06:46PM (#1569384)
While it's true that a handful of states have health plans, it would be advantageous to have a federal health plan, due to economies of scale. Furthermore, a federal health plan would ensure some consistency from state to state, making it easier to choose between health care, or your livelihood. Remember, some of us were cursed with poor genetics and are a guaranteed loss for any health insurance company.

Your statement suggesting that the government is more liberal than the population is unfounded. Recall, in the last Presidential election Barack Obama won on the currently enacted platform by a significant percentage. Furthermore, if people were actually aware and educated in political issues, it's my opinion that the country would lean more leftward. The only reason why any network or news source can possibly suggest the country is a center-right country is due to the vast perpetual amounts of mis-information and political propaganda.

It's also my opinion that the "Tea Party" are bogeyman. Their entire platform is empty of anything constructive, instead the platform seeks to incite, destroy, and push people apart. One need only look at Tea Party donor records to see who the Tea Party truly represents.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:43PM (#1569671)
"economies of scale"

What economies of scale kick in at a hundred million that you don't have at ten million?

Economies of scale have diminishing returns and those diminishing returns kick in long before the size of an American state, let alone at the national scale. The very real costs of having no competition will utterly dominate your economies of scale anyhow. And by dominate, I mean, utterly dominate.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by falien on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:29PM (#1569764)
Only 22 states have more than 5 million people. They have even fewer households. The whole idea of economies of scale is that they work better the bigger they are. Depending on the application there will usually be an equilibrium point, but your definition seems to be inverted. (And what serious politician was arguing for an immediate single payer system? Public option is just a government competitor to private companies)
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @11:26PM (#1570007)
"The whole idea of economies of scale is that they work better the bigger they are."

You just blipped over my point and did nothing to address it. Economies of scale aren't magical. They have diminishing returns. What economy of scale do you get at 100 million that you don't get at 10 million? That's a real question. If you can't answer it, or you answer it with something that just boils down to "Uh, something", you haven't countered my point.

But you know, even that's beside the point. People have completely lost the ability to understand freedom nowadays, which is why we're going to lose it. The alternative isn't "Federal plan or nothing", it's not even "Federal plan or 50 state plans", it's "Federal plan or States acting on their own". Believe it or not, and I realize this may be a cognitive shock which I recommend you actually think on for a moment, if poor little Rhode Island doesn't want to strike out on its own, it can actually form a partnership with, say, Delaware. Or nowadays for all geography matters, with California. If that doesn't work out, it can leave, it isn't stuck. Or it can choose to go on its own. Or it can leave it up to its counties. Or it can say "stuff it" and stick with a regulated private system. If the economies of scale are so all-important, than you shouldn't need to force people to take advantage of them at the point of a gun, they should choose it on their own!

(The real problem is that there almost certainly aren't any hidden economies of scale left. Where would they be hiding? Big Medicine is pretty Big already. "Economies of scale" is just an argument people make and hope you don't think about the argument too hard.)

It's never a choice between "the Feds do it" or "we sit on our hands", unless you've become so helpless that that really is your only choice. (And "you have to do everything on your own" isn't the other choice either. There's a ton of other options.)

And then we can find out what really works, because no plan survives contact with the enemy. Not even Federal plans.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by falien on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @12:11AM (#1570096)
I didn't blip over your argument, I rejected your premise. Economies of scale mean it works better the bigger it gets (up to a certain point in most cases which I already said, whether that point in this case is greater than a state or less than a country I'm not going to make any sort of claim on). If I'm manufacturing a widget my fixed costs aggregate over all widgets produced. A prototype is extremely expensive. The first 10 million are much cheaper. The next 90 million are even cheaper than that. Yes the benefits get less drastic on a per unit basis, but the total savings for that last 90 million could still be extremely significant. Whether this actually applies to health care I'm not about to say because its incredibly complex, but the idea that it would work is not an outrageous one.

Now that I'm done defining what scaling means... I think it would be great if the states could actually get it done, but the lower the office the less scrutiny is placed on an elected official and the more influence insurance companies can exert on them.

>The alternative isn't "Federal plan or nothing"

I'm well aware that federal action is not the only possibility, but I and many other people think it is the best one which is why we support it.

>you shouldn't need to force people to take advantage of them at the point of a gun

Who is advocating this? I would support single payer despite being in the class with incredibly low health care costs, but I know thats not going to happen any time soon so I advocate a public option. As the name implies, it is an option, not mandatory (as opposed to the boondoggle that actually got passed which I'm only okay with because it does have redeeming qualities that make up for the corporate handout). I believe state governments simply don't have the resources to set a system like this up.

Other arguments for federal action on this issue:

- it is a fundamental human right that must be protected at the highest levels. States protecting free speech doesn't mean federal doesn't need to.

- a uniform minimal baseline is desirable, on top of which the states can build how they choose.

>Big Medicine is pretty Big already.

Its objective is not to provide health care. Its objective is to generate profit. It is extremely good at generating profit, but not as good at providing quality health care for anyone who needs it.

>It's never a choice between "the Feds do it" or "we sit on our hands"

Who has ever said that it was? It may be the best choice we can get done.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by anamax on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:05PM (#1569585)
> While it's true that a handful of states have health plans, it would be advantageous to have a federal health plan, due to economies of scale.

Umm, the federal govt already runs a couple of massive health care systems. They don't do what single payer advocates promise, so why do you think that obamacare will?

I think that we should have given obama free reign wrt the healthcare of folks who currently get their healthcare from govt. Yes, military, state, local, and federal employees, Indian Health Service, Medicare, Medicaid, and so on.

We give him 2 years at the current budget then we cut 5% per covered person in the next four years. That's just over 20% which should be trivial given the promises of 30% savings.

If the covered population is better off at the end of that time, we can talk about expanding it.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by asnyder on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:23PM (#1569625)
Umm, the federal govt already runs a couple of massive health care systems. They don't do what single payer advocates promise, so why do you think that obamacare will?

What are you talking about? Members of VA, Medicare and Medicaid love their programs. You'd be hard pressed to find someone willing to give up their Medicare or VA benefits.

Medicare would do what a single payer advocates, if only we didn't include sweetheart deals. For example, Medicare Advantage, signed into law by Bush, and lobbied heavily for by the Insurance industry, did nothing but funnel money into private companies for the same benefits Medicare was already offering.

These programs would do what they're suppose to, if they weren't manipulated by corporate lobbyists or gutted by party partisans. So it's not surprising that when a program is legislated into the ground, those most responsible for those changes are the first ones to advocate the program's end. Interesting how that works.

Unfortunately, I'm not a member of the armed forces, don't qualify for Medicare, and not impoverished enough for Medicaid. If it wasn't for the recently passed health reform legislation my only option would be to crawl in some corner and die.

Thankfully my President helped to change that, and for the first time in over a year I'll finally be able to see my Neurologist and get that MRI I desperately need.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by anamax on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @10:46AM (#1571313)
> What are you talking about? Members of VA, Medicare and Medicaid love their programs. You'd be hard pressed to find someone willing to give up their Medicare or VA benefits.

You're overstating their satisfaction. However, since they're not paying, of course they won't give it up.

And, if you have a dispute, you're more likely to have it resolved in your favor if it's with a private company.

Medicare et al are pretty efficient at cutting a check. However, the low estimates of fraud are $50B/year.

> Medicare would do what a single payer advocates, if only we didn't include sweetheart deals.

And what makes you think that any new govt program will be any different? (Obamacare is full of such deals, so that's not a Republican thing.) You don't get to assume unicorns and puppies when the experience is very different.

That's why I wanted to give Obama free rein - to see if he could do better. However, Obamacare as passed ....

> Thankfully my President helped to change that, and for the first time in over a year I'll finally be able to see my Neurologist and get that MRI I desperately need.

Not to be rude, but "my president" isn't paying - I am.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by shasta on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:40PM (#1569788)
> "Unfortunately, I'm not a member of the armed forces, don't qualify for Medicare, and not impoverished enough for Medicaid."

I think you mean, "unfortunately, I don't have insurance."

Getting sick without insurance is a bummer, but if you're trying to get "insurance" after you get sick, that's not "insurance", it's "charity." Not that I know your circumstances or would necessarily mind chipping in my part to your getting the medical help you need.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by asnyder on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:57PM (#1569818)
I didn't get sick. I was born sick. Unfortunately, I inherited my father's genetics which have already resulted in one tumor being removed from my spine (I was 21).

I had insurance, since my father worked for the city. However, once I turned 24, that was all over. I'm a co-founder of a startup, as such it would be cost prohibitive to insure me, and incur undue charges on every other member and employee. As we grow, I'm sure we'll have enough employees at some point to offset my genetics, until then the recently passed health reform law is my only salvo.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by shasta on Monday August 02, 2010 @11:20PM (#1569993)
Well, I wish you good health, and based on what you've written I almost certainly don't mind chipping in. But, the point remains that you're already sick, so what you need now isn't insurance. I have extra sympathy for a kid that can't get insurance through no fault of his own, but I wonder - do you plan to have kids? Hypothetically, if there is a 50% shot of your children getting the same disease as you, and you choose to have them anyway, should everyone else have to pay the million dollar bill should they get sick?

Anyway, apologies if I sound bitter. I'm really not :)

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by sigstoat on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @02:18PM (#1572109)
my grandfather does not in fact love the VA, and would probably give the benefits up in exchange for just the money they spent on avoiding treating him.

based on your later comments, it sounds like you do actually have another option besides dying, which would be to stop trying to run your own business, and go work someplace large (10+ people most states?) enough that the insurance companies can't refuse you.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by falien on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:32PM (#1569770)
I'm pretty sure the promised savings were over private health care options. And the reasoning was that despite their incredible expense, the existing government systems for limited classes are more efficient than the private companies are. So give him a limited trial adding people to a government health care option for a few years and see if it is also more efficient.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by anamax on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:05PM (#1569584)
> One need only look at Tea Party donor records to see who the Tea Party truly represents.

How about a link?

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by asnyder on Monday August 02, 2010 @08:13PM (#1569601)
I'm sorry, I didn't realize it was necessary to make it so convenient for you. I expect the readers of HN are capable of doing Google searches or browsing through http://www.opensecrets.org/.

Next time I'll be sure to include a complete list of references.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by natep on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:18PM (#1569744)
While you have been around HN longer than I have, I believe the general feeling of HN is that the burden of proof is on the claimant, which would be you. So yes, please do include a list of references next time.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by asnyder on Monday August 02, 2010 @09:34PM (#1569772)
You don't find it a little odd that you feel it necessary that I provide the links and resources to easily findable information, but the commenter who I replied to need not substantiate his claims in a similar way? Especially when the burden of proof for those statements are much higher? In any event, downvote away. Let your prejudices rein supreme.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by anamax on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @01:25PM (#1575084)
> You don't find it a little odd that you feel it necessary that I provide the links and resources to easily findable information, but the commenter who I replied to need not substantiate his claims in a similar way?

Most of what he posted was his opinion. How would he substantiated that what he posted is actually his opinion?

You made a readily verifiable claim and got it wrong. In doing so, you actually provided evidence supporting one of his points.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by anamax on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @10:54AM (#1571353)
> I expect the readers of HN are capable of doing Google searches or browsing through http://www.opensecrets.org/.

I've done the searches - they don't show what you claimed. I asked because I could have missed something. So let's use your link and see what we find.

http://www.opensecrets.org/usearch/index.php?q=tea+party

shows three organizations, all local, which have raised $150k, $13k, and less than $1k.

That pretty much disproves your claim.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by asnyder on Thursday August 05, 2010 @12:46AM (#1577244)
What sort of nonsense is this? You do a search for tea party, which yields some small local organizations, with relatively no donations. When I refer to tea party, I'm referring to actual candidates. For example, Sharron Angle, Mark Rubio, Rand Paul.

Look at the PAC donations to these people. Look at the sort of people who contribute. You do a poor search and then conclude that I'm wrong based on your poor research ability.

Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by sigstoat on Thursday August 05, 2010 @12:38PM (#1578553)
it isn't clear to me how he was supposed to realize that by "tea party" you were actually referring to a specific list of politicians you had in mind, but had not named. would a different list of tea party-connected politicians suffice, or did he specifically need to guess those three in order to have good "research ability"?
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by rmc on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @10:20AM (#1571209)
I find anti-health care movement in America strange. In 50 years time it'll be political suicide to suggest removing it. Much like the 1960s civil rights acts, they were opposed at the time, but will be viewed as important by everyone in a few decades.
Re:American Nations: An attempt to hack (i.e., fix) American... by stevis on Monday August 02, 2010 @05:13PM (#1569109)
Nonsense. I'll reply at the top level though so i can answer other's questions, too.