Re:1962 glass could be Corning's next bonanza seller
by culled on Monday August 02, 2010 @02:23PM
(#1568501)
Of course a patent still wouldn't have helped in this case if it has been around for 50 years.
Re:1962 glass could be Corning's next bonanza seller
by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @02:45PM
(#1568579)
No, that's the exact opposite of my point. By patenting something, you stick in it the database of "public knowledge" so that it could be discovered 50 years later if need be. That means it wouldn't be necessary for Corning to sit on it for 50 years. Sitting on things for 50 years and making the current status of the filer irrelevant (dead, disincorporated, whatever) is one of the purposes of the patent system.
The "limited monopoly" is part of a social contract and understanding the whole contract is important.
Re:1962 glass could be Corning's next bonanza seller
by nickpinkston on Monday August 02, 2010 @07:07PM
(#1569446)
However, if they successfully commercialize sans patents - it'll be a good case against patents being needed to monetize. Finding markets, production advantages and expertise is still a bigger part of the equation than King George fencing off your market.
Realistically there are issues of course, but that's the theory.
(This is actually one of my core reasons to be against software patents; even if they otherwise worked as designed, in practice a lot of software patents are ten pages of legalese, half or more dedicated to simply enumerating the presence of a computer in the invention and various combinations of "on a network" and "with a disk drive" etc, and in the end the patent document is usually more of a spec then an implementation. If we really carried through on the logic of software patents, a software patent ought to require a software implementation in clear source code that is proved to implement the desired algorithm within a reference environment, and the source code should itself have no copyright protection. Combine that with a shorter term and I'd at least object much less, though I ultimately do agree in abolition in this domain; trade secrets and copyright are adequate to the task, if not already overkill.)
Somewhat more directly on topic, I bet 1960s and 1970s material science patents probably hold a few more things that are useful today that weren't useful then.