News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is a phD a good way to focus & motivate you? by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @01:21PM (#1568253)
If you have to ask yourself whether you want to do a PhD, the answer is no.
Re:Ask HN: Is a phD a good way to focus & motivate you? by throwaway1 on Monday August 02, 2010 @01:34PM (#1568318)
Can I ask why it is an outright 'no'? Is it not ok to ponder on something of this magnitude before diving in?
Re:Ask HN: Is a phD a good way to focus & motivate you? by apu on Monday August 02, 2010 @01:42PM (#1568350)
I think jerf means that for the vast majority of PhD students, the most motivation you're going to have is at the beginning. It only gets worse from there. So if you have serious doubts before diving in, you're almost certainly going to have real trouble during the PhD.
Re:Ask HN: Is a phD a good way to focus & motivate you? by jerf on Monday August 02, 2010 @02:54PM (#1568597)
Exactly; I meant that if you're not 100% sure already, you should probably stop.

In fact even being 100% sure itself probably isn't enough, but I for one will at least stop second-guessing you, since being able to perfectly predict who will succeed in advance is basically impossible.

This is a big life decision and it's exactly the wrong time to be a romantic about it. Trying and failing for a PhD is hugely expensive in opportunity cost. Trying, succeeding, and depending on a faculty post on the other end to make it all worthwhile can be pretty dangerous, too.

A lot of us in the 15-35 age range have been force-fed the idea growing up that encouragement is automatically good, regardless, and the entrepreneur community can be especially prone to this because you need a lot of drive to be an entrepreneur. I actually think that's ok for entrepreneurship, because the worst case isn't really all that bad unless you are really stupid. (Incorporate early, incorporate often; don't take on debt personally.) You at least get some very valuable experience. That's not true for everything. Getting your PhD is one of those things; a partial PhD is not worth it. I would be appalled if I encouraged someone to get their PhD and turned out to be that little tipping factor, only for them to find two years in that they are miserable and can't finish. If anything, a little light discouragement is what is really called for; if that's enough to turn you away from a PhD, then good! You were in trouble anyhow.

Life advice is serious business and unthinkingly spouting "common sense" can be very destructive.

But typing all this out is certainly less... pithy.

Re:Ask HN: Is a phD a good way to focus & motivate you? by T_S_ on Monday August 02, 2010 @02:56PM (#1568606)
A little simplistic I think. Big decisions should include the head and not just the gut.