News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by ChuckMcM on Sunday November 12, 2017 @02:26PM (#15682165)
That is an interesting question and one I've thought a bit about.

There is a strong sense of 'wrongness' in the US culture when Alice tells Bob a lie and Charlie knows it is a lie but Bob doesn't. Later Bob will be offended and ashamed that he believed Alice's lie to be the truth so in anticipation of that wrong, Charlie feels compelled to 'out' the lie and save Bob the embarrassment and hurt. Then when Donna, Edith, and Frank come to Alice's defense and double down on the lie Charlie goes apoplectic trying to defend against it for Bob's sake.

I think the challenge here is that uncontested lies that end up in the group consciousness as possible truths can have consequences that effect the group. Perhaps a bad example but one that has happened, is a community that gets a cell tower removed, reducing cell service to everyone in the community, because a group of them believe the cell tower is causing medical conditions to manifest in them.

Alice tells Bob his headaches are being caused by the cell tower, Charlie argues that she is mistaken, Donna, Edith, and Frank side with Alice and the tower is removed and now Charlie has to stand on the back corner of his porch to hit the cell tower one neighborhood over to make reliable phone calls. That is the sort of scenario Charlie fears that the lie persisting will create.

When people have a few experiences like that, where a lie they knew was a lie, came back and made their life poorer because it wasn't identified as such early on. They start having stronger and stronger reactions to lies like that. Sort of an escalating immune response if you will.

That is my current theory on why people get so worked up over stories like this.

Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by pfarnsworth on Sunday November 12, 2017 @02:44PM (#15682254)
I see your point, however, the level of vitriol I see is beyond reasonable. The poster is clearly offended beyond any sense of reasonableness by this story. And he is attacking these two as if they are some master criminals at work. They haven't asked for money as far as I can tell, and they don't even claim to be victims of very much except their own ineptitude. She even says she didn't feel like her life was at risk for any 24 hr period.

And yet, the blogger feels obsessed with going over the minutiae of this and trying to prove how these two are con artists, but I don't see the con. I feel like the anger is completely out of place, given the lack of crime, which is fascinating to me. And I've seen several posts like this, which is why it's something I've noticed specifically with this story.

Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by cjslep on Sunday November 12, 2017 @03:07PM (#15682370)
I think it's simply for the same reason people find Chris McCandless [0] polarizing. Communities don't like the media glorifying the grossly inexperienced among them. In this case, it happens to be the cross-ocean sailing community, which is not known for its eloquent lovey-dovey use of language.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_McCandless

Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by pattisapu on Monday November 13, 2017 @11:52AM (#15687826)
Yeah, it was kind of funny seeing this sailor, well, cursing like a sailor.
Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by michaelcampbell on Sunday November 12, 2017 @04:14PM (#15682659)
> And he is attacking these two as if they are some master criminals at work.

It sounds to me as if he's saying they are simply liars. And for what reason, no one can yet figure out. Not quite "masters" of anything.

Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by ChuckMcM on Sunday November 12, 2017 @03:01PM (#15682344)
I think the missing piece is that you can't see what assumptions the author is holding. I could imagine that the author is assuming that they will ask for or get some sort of movie or book deal, and they will get money for this event, while "knowing" that it is a giant lie or "con." The author may be trying to protect my fictional 'Bob' from being taken in by what he sees as their poor attempt at deception.

As for the minutiae, it seems to be a familiar response to the others who come to the defense with either implausible or improbable defensive statements like "while it is unlikely all of their radios died at once they could have." The author has gone apoplectic and wants people to know that the only facts he feels have the weight of truth are that these women were on a boat, the boat was originally in Hawaii, and that the Navy picked them up off the boat. He is just that offended by what he perceives as lies that others are "believing."

I would guess that his outrage is being fueled by his own experiences and what he sees as people being "gullible."

Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by mannykannot on Monday November 13, 2017 @09:42AM (#15686792)
I think you are basically right, though I don't think the explanation needs a specific hypothetical victim. Lying, like violence, is often used to advance the perpetrators' interests at the expense of others. When there are victims, most of us, I think, empathize with them and regard the perpetrators with at least distaste, even if we are at no risk of being victims ourselves, and even when the victims are unknown to us. If this were not the case - if we were only concerned with our immediate self-interest - ethical society probably could not exist.

Furthermore, knowing that someone has lied in the past leads us to distrust them, and even warn others about their behavior, even if there is no apparent victim, or even without clear evidence that they are currently being deceptive. Reputation is an important part of the network of trust that an ethical society depends on, and furthermore, we have probably all learned to be wary of deception even when we cannot immediately see the harm. Liars are suspected of being up to no good, and for good reason in general.

It also seems to be that blatant lying provokes more anger, even though subtle, minimal lying is often more effective, perhaps because blatant lying signals confidence in the perpetrator that he will prevail. In this case, the lying is blatant from the perspective of the author, who is knowledgable about the domain.

I recall a study from years ago - some sort of game-theoretic simulation - which showed, given its assumptions, that it was not enough that rule-breakers be punished for the society to remain whole, but so also should those who were tolerant of antisocial behavior. Unfortunately, I have lost track of it so I cannot check the plausibility of its assumptions, but note that someone getting away with something sometimes provokes more anger than the original offense, and then it often extends to those who permitted it. To the author, the lame rationalizations of the womens' defenders probably feels like collusion. Also, I see that in this thread, pfarnsworth's 'but there is no victim here' comment has been downvoted, while khazhou's 'no quarter' comment goes unremarked.

Re:Reasons the Jennifer Appel and Tasha Fuiava survival stor... by khazhou on Monday November 13, 2017 @12:02AM (#15684398)
Liars must be ruthlessly exposed, because they threaten our ability to trust each other.