Suppose the rich can buy everything they need with 1% of their income, sales tax is 10%. Then, the rich are paying 0.1% income tax. If the poor have to spend 20% of their income on the same necessities, they are paying twenty times more tax per amount of income.
From a theoretical perspective it seems to me that income tax would favor economic growth while sales tax, which can't be avoided, would depress economic growth.
No, it just doesn't disincentivize investment, same as sales tax.
Now let's say that I am planning to invest in some new equipment in the next 6 months.
If I buy the equipment now I don't have to pay taxes. If I wait I do.
How is that not an incentive to invest?
Every dollar in business expense is discounted by the amount of income tax not paid. The higher the income tax the greater the discount on business expenses and the greater the incentive to do something with cash other that hoarding it.
If you wait until the next year, you'll don't have to pay the taxes next year instead of not paying them this year.
But my point is about income vs sales tax:
- 0 % sales tax, 10% income tax:
You don't pay taxes on what you invest (assuming deduction)
- 10 % sales tax, 0% income tax:
You don't pay taxes on what you invest (assuming deduction)
Result: You cannot claim that people are investing more just because you have income tax.
You could of course assume that putting a tax on everything except investment will encourage investment. But it's the same as if you raise the price of everything except water to encourage the consumption of water.
If you ask why this wouldn't work, think about how taxes affect disposable income.
IMO the latter is preferable because of the above plus it doesn't accrue.