Re:H1-B Administrators Are Challenging an Unusually Large Nu...
by dragonwriter on Saturday November 11, 2017 @11:02PM
(#15679579)
> It seems to be a matter for economic theory
No, it's mostly a matter of disagreement on fundamental values, not about whether the factual effects of the policy are in line with or opposed to an agreed set of values.
Re:H1-B Administrators Are Challenging an Unusually Large Nu...
by projectramo on Sunday November 12, 2017 @12:59AM
(#15679886)
That’s just false.
That would be true only if the “factual effects” were agreed upon.
Let me give you an example: Pro immigration advocates claim immigration will increase US jobs. So do anti immigration activists.
Re:H1-B Administrators Are Challenging an Unusually Large Nu...
by dragonwriter on Sunday November 12, 2017 @01:55AM
(#15680002)
> That would be true only if the “factual effects” were agreed upon.
No, he fact that there is a conflict of values which includes a fundamental disagreement on which facts are relevant and how the same facts would weigh in desirability is true independent of whether there is agreement on the facts of the economic effects of immigration (there isn't, but the fact remains that the dispute on policy is largely not about facts, but goals.)
You either believe:
1. That a person is good for the country because they work, earn, spend and contribute to productivity.
2. They are taking a job that would have otherwise gone to an American, and are transferring money from laborers to the corporation.
It seems to be a matter for economic theory. What do studies show? Does a worker produce as many high paying jobs as they displace?
It seems odd that we aren't pulling out references, debating over statistics and methodology and so on. There is an actual answer to the question: does immigration add to productivity or reduce consumption. (Both you say? Great, show me a study!)