News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Driverless shuttle in Las Vegas gets in fender bender wit... by dragonwriter on Thursday November 09, 2017 @07:56PM (#15667111)
> Except the driver-less shuttle didn't take any evasive action, the way a human would have.

Stopping was an evasive action, and since the result was a graze, it may have been moderately successful. While the people on the bus seem (from the article) to think there was time for more action, the perception of time under the adrenaline rush of an imminent collision may be misleading.

Re:Driverless shuttle in Las Vegas gets in fender bender wit... by phil21 on Thursday November 09, 2017 @08:26PM (#15667244)
> the perception of time under the adrenaline rush of an imminent collision may be misleading.

This may be one of the more ridiculous excuses I've seen for self driving vehicle "screwups".

Is the argument actually computers can't take action instantly compared to a human? If so, then self driving cars may as well not exist.

It's well within a computer's capability to take evasive action for an accident like this far before a human driver - assuming sufficient sensor input. This is exactly the reason I want to see self driving tech rapidly accelerate - a car that has it's situational awareness 100% at all times, and thus can react instantly in a safe manner to any situation.

I understand the software is not up to that point yet - and your response is exactly what I fear the most. I see endless DoS attacks against self driving cars once they get even a remotely substantial percentage of the market.

If all programming reverts to "failsafe stop when things may be remotely potentially unsafe" we are going to see traffic problems of a proportion we have never experienced.

Re:Driverless shuttle in Las Vegas gets in fender bender wit... by thethirdone on Thursday November 09, 2017 @08:34PM (#15667275)
>> the perception of time under the adrenaline rush of an imminent collision may be misleading.

>This may be one of the more ridiculous excuses I've seen for self driving vehicle "screwups".

>Is the argument actually computers can't take action instantly compared to a human? If so, then self driving cars may as well not exist.

No, I don't think that's what the parent comment meant. It means that the people who said that it didn't take proper action (that were there) may have been mistaken in thinking there was more time to act than there was.

Re:Driverless shuttle in Las Vegas gets in fender bender wit... by eloff on Thursday November 09, 2017 @09:40PM (#15667529)
Not enough time for a computer to react, but enough time for people to think it could have? I seriously doubt that. Yeah, the average human driver might have also just frozen, or only honked, but the computer has excellent situational awareness (it had better if it's driving on public roads) so it knows if it can backup suddenly safely. A human would have to look over their shoulder. It should also honk the horn, I mean that's just low-hanging fruit to implement. Clearly they detected the truck and stopped, what's wrong with stop() && honk().
Re:Driverless shuttle in Las Vegas gets in fender bender wit... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 09, 2017 @07:58PM (#15667117)
But a human facing an imminent collision, under the adrenaline rush, can often take more evasive action than there seems to be time for (if they don't freeze).