Re:Conrad Black: My prison education
by halostatue on Sunday August 01, 2010 @10:09PM
(#1566619)
Lord Black is not a Canadian patriot. A patriot would not have given his citizenship up for power and dubious honours. There are things that COULD have been done without forcing the loss of his citizenship, such as honourary knighthoods. Instead, he decided he wanted something explicitly prohibited by Canadian law.
I believe that Conrad Black committed fraud; I also believe he was railroaded by the American legal system. It's good that he can fight this because he has money and powerful friends, but America should do better. I find it interesting that Black decries the public defender system (and it IS broken) but offers no ideas for what could fix or replace it.
It's not prohibited by law. Canadian law has no jurisdiction in other countries.
Also, if titular honors are prohibited by foreign governments why do we have a Queen?
Re:Conrad Black: My prison education
by halostatue on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @12:23PM
(#1571701)
A quick search shows up the Nickle Resolution:
http://www.canadianencyclopedia.ca/index.cfm?PgNm=TCE&Pa... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_titles_debate
Canadians are (like Americans, although for different reasons) prohibited from accepting foreign titles. That's pretty much "against the law" to me.
I applaud Black for fighting it all the way and because he fought it all the way this one of many egregious statutes will no longer be used to put innocent people in jail. If the state could have proved a fraud charge they would have, but they couldn't. You don't get unanimous supreme court victories by accident. The law was clearly illegal.
Lord Black is an example Canadians should hold high who rejected his country by giving up citizenship rather than letting politics get in the way of much deserved honours. He is a true patriot.