Re:Social Media Has Failed Its Self-Driving Test
by Chaebixi on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:04PM
(#15664925)
> Perhaps the author does not understand the logistical nightmare of having human moderators manually approve all content.
Pretty sure he does, from the OP:
> A step back to assert human control -- even if it cuts into the tech companies wide profit margins -- is overdue indeed.
The tech companies use these algorithms because they're cheap and they're good-enough for their profit-making purposes. If Google's algorithms can't keep YouTube Kids kid-friendly, then they need to hire the human moderators to make up the difference or kill the product (because it's false advertising).
Re:Social Media Has Failed Its Self-Driving Test
by deong on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:52PM
(#15664812)
I don't think the author cares about the logistics of it, nor should he. If you offer me a service, it's up to you to figure out how to provide that service. If doing so is a logistical nightmare, then you're failing uphold your end of the bargain. No one is forcing YouTube to market a kid's channel.
As to whether today's AI is up to the task, I think it's fairly hard to say definitively. It seems certain that we haven't yet fielded a system that does it very well though.
Further, the fact that YouTube, Facebook, et al. Have failed to police content to the author's satisfaction is not indicative of a failure in AI - especially when these corporations are effectively incentivized by view counts and advertisement not to remove these videos.
In short, YouTube's failure is not a valid indicator of the effecticeness of AI in general.