Re:Apple Was Right To Kill Flash
by ThomPete on Sunday August 01, 2010 @06:04PM
(#1566212)
There is nothing right in what Apple has decided to do.
Apple has the right to do it but that's another thing.
Whether flash dies or not I don't really care about. I would though prefer to see it die out because developers and end users decided they should leave it rather than some industry king pin forces it out of his devices.
However great HTML5 is going to be it's not by any metrics close to something like http://audiotool.com/.
We can argue what is the future of the web, but this attempt to force Flash out of different platforms even before there is any real alternative is really sad.
Flash for better or worse is the de-facto best and most widespread technology we have for these kind of experiences. And there is much interesting experimentation being done with that platform just as with HTML5.
But the difference is that HTML5 is trying to do things that Flash did well 3-4 years ago if not more. And that to me at least shows that HTML5 isn't ready to take over anything neither from a consumer nor a developers perspective.
Re:Apple Was Right To Kill Flash
by mitjak on Sunday August 01, 2010 @06:05PM
(#1566213)
You know what's sad? That you can't save anything in Audio Tool! I spent at least 2-3 hours tinkering with it only to discover I can merely immortalize my efforts into an MP3.
Apple has the right to do it but that's another thing.
Whether flash dies or not I don't really care about. I would though prefer to see it die out because developers and end users decided they should leave it rather than some industry king pin forces it out of his devices.
However great HTML5 is going to be it's not by any metrics close to something like http://audiotool.com/.
We can argue what is the future of the web, but this attempt to force Flash out of different platforms even before there is any real alternative is really sad.
Flash for better or worse is the de-facto best and most widespread technology we have for these kind of experiences. And there is much interesting experimentation being done with that platform just as with HTML5.
But the difference is that HTML5 is trying to do things that Flash did well 3-4 years ago if not more. And that to me at least shows that HTML5 isn't ready to take over anything neither from a consumer nor a developers perspective.