News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by goodroot on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @04:35PM (#15657302)
I understand the argument regarding power consumption.

However, if we're going to green wash (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenwashing) a cryptocurrency, we need to focus on more than power consumption.

Given that power is getting cheaper and cleaner through solar[1, 2], this is asking people to further accumulate more waste and precious metals in the form of fixed drives. This is not eco-friendly and it's dubious to assert such.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-22/solar-pow... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-03/for-cheap...

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by freeloop3 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @05:10PM (#15657605)
Bitcoin adjusts difficulty based on how many people mine it. So cheap power doesn't reduce the cost, since it will just mean even more mining.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by tpallarino on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @05:33PM (#15657782)
Exactly, the amount of money spent on energy to mine is equal to the amount of mining revenue. Energy consumption is more closely related to price.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by jwilliams on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:46PM (#15658310)
Nod - I'm coming to the conclusion that the effective store of value is the mining infrastructure. Even if it's not that explicit, they move in lock-step.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by codemac on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @08:48PM (#15659059)
This is the exact same conclusion Marx came to about labor.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by simplify on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:12PM (#15659527)
Could you expand on this?
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by zhte415 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:52PM (#15659703)
The value of a product is equivalent to the amount of labour exerceted in its production.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:10AM (#15660258)
"The value of a product is equivalent to the amount of labour exerceted in its production"

This is one of the most problematic statements ever made in Econ.

The 'value' of a product is different for everyone, and it's what you (or anyone else) will pay for it.

The idea that 'work = value' is one of the most distortionary ideas in business, even today.

Just had a discussion today about pricing a product, and it was derived from component prices. Trying to convince a room of people that 'price is not a function of cost' ... in 2017.

Yes - when things are commodities, often, price is a function of cost, because competitive pricing means just a small margin above cost, which will roughly be the same for most.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by codemac on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:35AM (#15660341)
Exactly, which is why Marx uses the concept of a labor value, use value, and exchange value.

Labor is what's gone in, use is the inherent/intrinsic value in the object, and exchange value is what people will trade in exchange for it. That's a bad summary, and there's a lot more to the dialectic examination of them.

Reading Capital (along with David Harvey's lectures) is worth it if you find these things interesting, it's a deep analysis of markets and capital.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by owlmirror on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:51AM (#15660642)
It still ignores scarcity and arbitrarily picks one specific limiting resource in the production process as essential. Labor theory of value might be interesting from a philosophical standpoint but really has no practical application when it comes to understanding the market. And it introduces a major can of worms when it presumes stuff like intrinsic value.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:59AM (#15661167)
It doesn't ignore scarcity, scarce goods are inherently more labor intensive. And it doesn't presume intrinsic value, the labor necessary is a subjective concept so the value must be as well.

You're probably right about it's use in understanding a capitalist market, Marx spends no shortage of time on how capitalists warp that basic idea.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by fvdessen on Thursday November 09, 2017 @08:59AM (#15662369)
How are scarce goods more labour intensive ? It doesn't take any more labour to make a good wine than a bad one.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Thursday November 09, 2017 @09:57AM (#15662879)
Then why are bad wines made? Making better wine requires more training, more time, better tools, and/or better grapes. All four require more labor.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Thursday November 09, 2017 @10:22AM (#15663110)
That has little to do with 'scacity'.

Also - it's entirely possible that you make spectacular wine with the same effort I make bad wine.

They are somehow 'equal' in value?

It's just ridiculous. Labour theory of value just doesn't have a lot of meaning.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:22PM (#15664114)
If your example isn't scarcity I don't know what to tell you, if better wine is "scarce" those labors are what is needed to make better wine.

Explain how it is possible, and how the situation does not immediately solve itself with you stopping doing something you hate and are bad at.

As many have pointed out, "value" is subjective. Your terrible wine may be loved by someone. Or you may really enjoy making wine. As wine has zero intrinsic value, it is a luxury good, it's very possible for both wines to be just as valuable.

It has plenty of meaning, it just doesn't explain "profit."

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:52PM (#15664332)
One wine being generally better than another, is not about 'scarcity'.

Yes - of course people will have differing opinions - but aggregate market demand can be different for something made with the same amount of labour - that is not an issue of scarcity.

i.e. 'most people' can view one wine as better than the other with equal amounts of labour.

Again - surely you can, if you want get into issues of 'scarcity' i.e. you can talk about production volumes etc. but that's kind of a second order issue.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:18PM (#15665049)
I also found the wine example peculiar, as good wine and scarce wine aren't often the same, but I kept with it as it was brought up. Mistakenly I thought you had brought it up, sorry.

"Aggregate market demands" are capitalism, where wine is a status symbol and "good" wine generally refers to price. You are continuing to view this only in the eyes of capitalism and considering "value" to include "profit."

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Thursday November 09, 2017 @05:09PM (#15666238)
""Aggregate market demands" are capitalism, where wine is a status symbol and "good" wine generally refers to price"

No - what I meant by 'aggregate market demand' was really just 'average price / perception of value' - and 'good' does not refer to 'price' - good wine literally is better.

I am not equating value and profit. I am equating value and price.

Some goods are generally better than others (i.e. most people will think one is better than the other) and require the same labour - this is my point - and it's unrelated to scarcity.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Thursday November 09, 2017 @05:54PM (#15666447)
Like I said, someone else brought up the wine example and I just continued it despite finding it clumsy.

Price is value plus profit, thats the only reason to distinguish between the two.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by fvdessen on Friday November 10, 2017 @07:56AM (#15669517)
I think my original point about wine was misunderstood. Good wine is not good because it is scarce, it is good because it is good, but it is more expensive because it is scarce.

If you could produce infinite quantities of Chateau-Petrus, it would be extremely cheap. But since it depends on being produced at a specific location, with a specific know-how, the quantities are limited. In this case, the amount of labour involved has little effect on the price of the wine.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Friday November 10, 2017 @11:34AM (#15671001)
First, and this isn't really relevant, price and scarcity play a much bigger role in what is considered "good wine" than you're saying.

Back on topic, "expensive" and "price" again add the concept of profit to the value produced. The only value of wine is enjoyment, so even Petrus wine has little more value than similar wines.

That increase in value is largely labor from learning the trade and long running slow maintenance. The only part that is scarce is the soil composition, something that could be recreated with a large amount of labor. Similarly, discovering that that area produced quality wine was labor intensive as well.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Friday November 10, 2017 @12:26PM (#15671389)
" Good wine is not good because it is scarce, it is good because it is good, but it is more expensive because it is scarce."

No - not at all.

Good wine can be 'more expensive' simply because it is better!

There's more willingness to pay, i.e. better demand curve!

Doesn't need to be less supply!

Point being: not all labour is equal, ergo, the idea of something being valued upon the 'amount of labour' put into it is really not useful.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:15PM (#15672588)
I am not doing a strong job explaining this subject, but you are dismissing it out of hand without an understanding of it. I recommend taking codemac's advice and reading some of Marx's work. Even if you disagree with him it provides a greater understanding of how the economy works.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:20PM (#15673558)
I did read it (a long time ago) and I don't agree with him.

I just don't believe the labour theory of value is a useful concept.

I don't think Marx provides any understanding of how the economy works - other than to hint strongly that prices are really a function of power - i.e. when one group has a monopoly on some critical thing, i.e. land or capital, then they can use that to leverage over another group, and then you have basically class struggle.

I mean, it's useful rhetoric, I'm not sure if it's useful theory.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by keganunderwood on Friday November 10, 2017 @10:11PM (#15674796)
In my opinion, you don't even need Marx for this. Even Jeff Bezos reportedly said "your margin is my opportunity". So if some product is expensive without being scarce, it is probably being "protected" by likely unethical means (like copyright?) or an oligopoly (unions?) that keeps prices artificially high.

Sorry if this missed the mark completely. Would love to learn.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Thursday November 09, 2017 @10:20AM (#15663092)
I don't think the 'labour' concept of value has any meaning at all.

Given how much our labour is amplified by machines, energy, machine intelligence, parts, equipment, R&D, support - it's not a very helpful way to think about anything.

It's also very unhelpful when considering prices of IP related things.

You study your whole life to become a great actor, you make a film - it only takes a month. Is it only a 'one month film'? Equivalent to the quality of a newby actor?

Almost everything requires at least some skill ...

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by codemac on Friday November 10, 2017 @11:49AM (#15671105)
It depends -- how would we price things when everything takes 0 labor from humans?

Because I bet the price changes drastically, and that's the labor-value represented in object.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by int_19h on Friday November 10, 2017 @04:33AM (#15668865)
> The 'value' of a product is different for everyone, and it's what you (or anyone else) will pay for it.

Marx did not dispute that. His point, rather, was that workers are paid significantly less than the actual value of the work that they do (because said value is directly measured by how much their product sold for, minus all the non-labor expenses).

And from there he concluded that the difference is the economic rent that the owner of the means of production is effectively extracting from those workers, by virtue of his ownership giving him the monopoly on them (or rather, by virtue of the capitalist class collectively having a monopoly on the means of production).

And that, being pure rent, it does not serve any useful purpose in the economy, except for the one collecting it - i.e. things would be more efficient if people couldn't collect rent like that, which he proposed to achieve by rejecting the notion that means of production can be privately owned in a way that also bestows ownership of whatever is produced by them.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by parasubvert on Friday November 10, 2017 @07:27AM (#15669414)
The part he missed was there was value in risk taking, innovation, experimentation. The profits aren’t always completely a rent (though they can be in an uncompetitive market). Profit often covers real costs in a dynamic economy.

“Profit motive” was bunk psychology created by 19th century economists to explain away this discrepancy.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by boomboomsubban on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:41AM (#15660361)
This isn't a problematic statement in economics, its a problematic statement in capitalism where the equation is "value=labor+profit." Subjective value isn't a problem as finding someone who values it a certain amount takes more labor.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by snarfybarfy on Thursday November 09, 2017 @07:47AM (#15661915)
The product you seem to be talking about is not part of 'the market'. Otherwise competition would drive the price down to intrinsic cost + small profit (remember the 'invisible hand'?)

10 years and 1000's of lawyers to find out whether Microsoft is a monopoly? Give me a break! Just look at their income statement! Profit margins of 30% and more for 30 or more years? Do you seriously believe nobody would or could do the same for 20% profits?

A real market economy would tax away most of the excess profits after a certain number of years (depending on industry?). But then you would not have Apple and Microsoft and all your other beloved monopolists.

Ps: I'm a bit undecided but maybe it's OK for luxury products to not be part of the market. If you want to pay $200 more for an additional 1 GB on your iPhone when the price for 1 GB is $20, then it's no skin of my nose. But please make sure Apple pays their taxes.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alexasmyths on Thursday November 09, 2017 @10:17AM (#15663074)
"tax away most of the excess profits"

How do you define 'excess profits'.

And BTW - yes - I really do believe 'nobody can compete with Microsoft'.

Do you realize how sophisticated those products are?

And for every MS product, there are tons of competitors.

MS doesn't just make a 'widget' - they depend upon the talent (and ability to evolve that), deep value chain integration, R&D - it's a constantly moving team.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by snarfybarfy on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @06:01AM (#15694069)
Taxing excess profits should be somewhat analogous to patents. (Well, except for the huge mess that patents these days are, but I am more talking about the conceptual reasoning behind them).

The creator gets a time limited monopoly to pay for his efforts. Nobody ever thought having an unlimited monopoly was good for society (well except for the guys actually having the monopoly, cuz you know it trickles down somehow).

Regarding the quality of MS products, why it's obvious that they used some of their monopoly rents to hire smart people to work on it.

But the point still stands that they were and still are a monopoly. Otherwise someone equally smart would have broken into their market and pushed profit margins down.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by goldenkey on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:46AM (#15660177)
Except this ignores scarcity. And also ignores post-scarcity; this is the time period when robots do all work and farm all resources leaving humanity to decide the value of things divorced from rarity and labour. I will concede to Marx one aspect of his maxim; that is, scarcity is directly correlated with human effort towards a reseller market. So it still applies even if indirectly. For example, there is less labour spent trying to skim off the top of automotive mechanics work than labour spent reselling gold or limited edition Nike Airheads, etc....
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by alfiedotwtf on Thursday November 09, 2017 @06:25AM (#15661529)
The problem with mining rigs is that they have high upfront cost AND a short life span. Once a faster rig comes out, NOT upgrading is effectively a tax against future profits
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by himalay on Thursday November 09, 2017 @07:42AM (#15661893)
Sad but true
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by fe2ijwe99 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:56PM (#15658381)
Isn't that true of basically any computing task?

Can't generate AI, websites, etc with the computing infrastructure.

No software patents if no computers to create software.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by jwilliams on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @08:22PM (#15658903)
At a really abstract level, yes. However, many computing tasks generate results that can be used near-infinitely. For example, that supercomputer that generates the weather can distribute the results to every person in the region.

Whereas in cryptocurrency, that's split. The miners provide security and integrity for the chain. They also take their own very specific fee.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by zby on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:04AM (#15660457)
The real problem is that when miners are competitive they'll always add cost (in electricity, equipment and whatever) up to the level of the revenues. So if you have a block reward - it will approximate the cost of the system. There is a famous post on this subject: Nothing is Cheaper than Proof of Work http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/ (even though I believe that Proof of Stake can be cheaper: https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-stake-can-be-cheaper-than-p... - by reducing the block reward).
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by lowglow on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:21AM (#15660523)
You can see Bram announce this a month ago at the local Crypto Builders Meetup[0]. He talks about it in depth.

Skip to 32m: https://www.facebook.com/hackdays4all/videos/533001907045477...

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by xelxebar on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @08:14PM (#15658855)
I don't get why PV, wind, geothermal &c get so much more love than the various nuclear fuel cycles.

AFAIK nuclear so far has the smallest fatality per kWh ratio. For certain, salt reactors need a lot more research, but so do many of these other "green" energies. Are we even clear on the full environmental impact of the various "green" energies when factoring in secondary and tertiary costs?

I feel like China probably has the right idea of dumping a bunch of R&D into LFTR and whatnot instead of riding the Eco Friendly TM train.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by tom_mellior on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:24AM (#15661007)
For many people it's fatalities, yes. For others like me, it's about not leaving nuclear waste around for many thousands of years. That is, "factoring in secondary and tertiary costs", including ones not necessarily expressed in today's dollars.

The world would be all over a nuclear fuel cycle that doesn't produce waste that needs very-long-term storage.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by noonespecial on Thursday November 09, 2017 @09:15AM (#15662506)
Nuclear's great but even if we could magik up a few dozen reactors tomorrow, our distribution infrastructure still sucks (in the USA at least).

Wind and solar seem to address both of these problems. Very likely faster, cheaper, safer availability and goes a long way to decentralizing distribution and easing the "long wires everywhere" problem.

Nuclear probably still has some very compelling use cases in niche areas but on the whole, its time as "the power of the future" seems past.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by Marazan on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:36AM (#15661072)
If this was 15 years ago I'd be saying "Nuclear, hell yeah".

But in the last 15 years solar prices have come way the heck down. And are going to go down even further in the coming 15 years. Everyone will get solar panels, they will be just that cheap.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by totalZero on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:48PM (#15659685)
> I don't get why PV, wind, geothermal &c get so much more love than the various nuclear fuel cycles.

Perceived tail risk.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by pjc50 on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:50AM (#15661134)
Among other things, nuclear has a ridiculous cost overrun problem. We can't wait for it to be cheap, we have to deploy the working renewables now while waiting for "better" nuclear to be researched and built.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by rtpg on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:53PM (#15659430)
full lifecycle studies are constantly being done on all power sources, the idea of factoring in the entire process has almost always been there.

Solar energy being a great solution to power generation is backed by a lot of research, as well as a good economic situation. It's not just a bandwagon.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by whyever on Thursday November 09, 2017 @05:10AM (#15661221)
> AFAIK nuclear so far has the smallest fatality per kWh ratio.

Does that include the uranium miners?

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by eeZah7Ux on Thursday November 09, 2017 @07:20AM (#15661787)
More importantly, does that includes the projected fatalities due to power plants being destroyed and nuclear waste being unearthed and released in the environment?

Given the half life of waste, ignoring that risk is ludicrous.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by corford on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:07PM (#15659497)
He seems to have thought about this and answers a question on it here (at about 1hr8mins in): https://www.facebook.com/BerkeleyBlockchain/videos/200606982...

His answer is a bit hand wavy though (or maybe I'm just being slow).

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by littlestymaar on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:02PM (#15657991)
Praising solar and being concerned about accumulating wastes in the same sentence is pretty ironic imo.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by jjeaff on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:31PM (#15658193)
Get your startup plan in order. In 20 years you can become the "Uber" of solar panel disposal. Because you can't even throw away a fluorescent bulb with most garbage collection services. Imagine the amount of toxic chemicals we will need to get rid of when these solar panels start to wear out en masse.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by kurthr on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:59PM (#15658397)
Why would you throw out a paid for PV system? It's a sunk cost unless you're running out of roof space and need more power. The efficiency only drops some 20% over 20 years.

Also, they can be reasonably recycled... http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/articles/2016/06/solar-p...

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by littlestymaar on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:31AM (#15660566)
Maybe because after some time they eventually die.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by legohead on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @07:28PM (#15658596)
When there are no more bitcoins to mine, will the power consumption drastically fall? There will be fees to mine, but I can't imagine everyone is going to be fighting that much on fees, but I don't really know..
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by johnvonneumann on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:27AM (#15660313)
You would hope that in 140~ years we have the power problem sorted out, if not, Bitcoin mining is probably the least of our worries.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by Marazan on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:39AM (#15661084)
The power expended on mining directly correlates to the value of bitcoins. If the amount of power expended on mining decreases to far then it becomes cost effective to attack the network.

Power expended on mining must remain constant or ever increasing lest the whole thing collapse.

Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by jacobush on Thursday November 09, 2017 @08:17AM (#15662086)
This is where it gets interesting. Bitcoin miners only reward then are transaction fees. So these must go up.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by petre on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:50PM (#15659950)
No. They will flee to mining other crypto currencies. If all of this turns out to be e big Ponzi scheme or becomes illegal and just about everyone loses interest in mining crypto currencies, maybe then will power consumption fall.
Re:BitTorrent inventor announces eco-friendly Bitcoin compet... by Grangar on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:11AM (#15660947)
As difficulty rises bitcoin payouts will decrease asymptotically. The idea is to let the market do its work and have the price make up for it.