Re:Google Working to Remove MINIX-Based Management Engine fr...
by peatmoss on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:24AM
(#15653923)
Looking at https://raptorcs.com/TALOSII/, the main cost to getting a POWER9 CPU isn't the CPU itself, it's paying a relatively small mainboard design company that needs to recoup their (presumably substantial) engineering costs.
Given Google's size, I wonder:
1) If they could reasonably design their own mainboards for POWER9
2) If they could create a market for POWER9 CPUs among enthusiasts and the security minded (Google's apparent motivation for lobotomizing Intel ME)
3) If the POWER9 CPU is a reasonable option for their workloads
4) If other architectures are a non-starter from a homogeneity standpoint (e.g. everything else runs Intel, and software compatibility is king).
Re:Google Working to Remove MINIX-Based Management Engine fr...
by rbanffy on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:46AM
(#15654108)
If that motherboard could fit in a reasonable desktop tower chassis, it'd be cool to be able to piggyback on Google's and Rackspace's work.
BTW, I assume both companies would somehow benefit from having machines like those on engineer's desks - it's certainly convenient to do local development on the platform you are deploying to.
Re:Google Working to Remove MINIX-Based Management Engine fr...
by rbanffy on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:50AM
(#15654168)
This piece focuses on Google's attempt at removing ME 11 code and replace it with something they are more comfortable with. The others drove discussion towards numbers, security issues and a third one focused on the license (BSD) and its effects.
Yeeeowch. That's a pretty egregious error.
Given Google's size, I wonder:
1) If they could reasonably design their own mainboards for POWER9
2) If they could create a market for POWER9 CPUs among enthusiasts and the security minded (Google's apparent motivation for lobotomizing Intel ME)
3) If the POWER9 CPU is a reasonable option for their workloads
4) If other architectures are a non-starter from a homogeneity standpoint (e.g. everything else runs Intel, and software compatibility is king).
EDIT: Formatting
BTW, I assume both companies would somehow benefit from having machines like those on engineer's desks - it's certainly convenient to do local development on the platform you are deploying to.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15641592
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15634014
In the end, though, they're all Unixy enough.