News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by tskaiser on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:56AM (#15652971)
IANAL but it is my understanding that if those tax reduction schemes are legal many companies are legally bound by their stock holders to exploit them, or else be found negligent in their duties.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by pavlov on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:03AM (#15653043)
>... if those tax reduction schemes are legal many companies are legally bound by their stock holders to exploit them, or else be found negligent in their duties.

That's not the case. There is no way a company's management could be sued for "gross negligence in tax planning".

If shareholders are unhappy about this issue, their recourse is the same one that's always available to them: elect a new Board of Directors and hire new management that will follow the board's guidance on tax evasion schemes.

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by tskaiser on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:23AM (#15653911)
I admit to be completely out of my depth, but my understanding is that it is a fiduciary duty of the directors to act in the best interest of the shareholders. Tax planning is a huge part of profit and thus shareholder value, so wouldn't such "gross negligence" represent a breach of fiduciary duty?
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by pavlov on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:04PM (#15654335)
Suing directors for negligence is not easy at all. It's hard to imagine a shareholder lawsuit that basically says: "As a director you didn't guide management to move operations to Jersey, so we want you to pay us $100 million"... It's even harder to imagine a US court being friendly to such a case.

The greatest example of board negligence in this industry (that I can think of) in recent years would be when Hewlett-Packard's board hired Léo Apotheker as CEO in 2010. The board members had never met the man and his career had been on a different continent, yet they didn't even interview him in person before giving him the job!

Apotheker spent $10.2 billion to buy a British company named Autonomy. Soon after he was fired. Only a year later, HP was forced to write down $8.8 billion of Autonomy's purchase price.

That enormous loss was directly the fault of HP's board for hiring such a terrible CEO and letting him do the terrible deal. But shareholders didn't have any recourse; the best they could do is vote on a new board.

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by tskaiser on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:13PM (#15654432)
Thank you for the insight. It is one thing what holds in theory, and quite another what happens in reality, as you point out.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by jmalicki on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @02:19PM (#15655934)
It is actually quite common.

Here is a list of hundreds of such open lawsuits:

http://shareholdersfoundation.com/content/new-cases

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by pavlov on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @02:28PM (#15656034)
Yes, shareholder lawsuits are common. But it's the company that pays, not directors.

HP actually paid $100 million in such a lawsuit for the Apotheker/Autonomy flop:

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-hp-classaction-pggm/hp-pay...

The 2010 Board of Directors who created and permitted the $8.8 billion loss paid nothing. They kept their compensation, and most stayed on the board.

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by jmalicki on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @02:24PM (#15655987)
In Seinfeld v. Slager (2012) the Delaware Chancery Court rejected the notion that the directors have a fiduciary duty to minimize taxes.

https://www.delawarelitigation.com/2012/07/articles/chancery...

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by dijit on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:08AM (#15653100)
What if they've done that already though.

What if the reason big companies avoid tax is that the shareholders ensure someone values fiscal results over supporting the country they earned the finance in is in the directors chair.

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by pavlov on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:27AM (#15653328)
Yes, that's exactly why American corporations do the things they do.

It's not a legal obligation though. Shareholders could choose to have corporations managed differently. That kind of "pro-tax" activist shareholders don't exist, but it's not inconceivable that large public funds (pensions etc.) could become such.

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by Flenser on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:51AM (#15653584)
Perhaps if governments started penalising corporate tax avoidance by confiscating a percentage of a company's shares the shareholders would be incentivised to make sure whoever is running the company will pay taxes fairly.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by an_account on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:04AM (#15653723)
And how should the government define “tax avoidance”? With tax law? Oh wait, they already do it, and you get pentalized if you break it.

The problem isn’t Apple, the problem is the government can’t get its act together to pass tax reform.

Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by Roodgorf on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:11AM (#15653140)
If companies are duty-bound to act unethically (if legally) for the sake of share holder profits then I think that speaks to a flaw in the system driving these decisions.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by nobodyorother on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:39PM (#15654742)
But they aren't, not even in Delaware. That's a common misconception that greedy folks love to spread.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by pwinnski on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:42PM (#15655527)
This is a common misperception, but it is incorrect. There is no fiduciary duty to avoid or minimize tax, and conversely no legal duty to maximize taxes either. It is up to each company to choose how aggressively they pursue these tax-avoiding strategies.
Re:Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook by MaxfordAndSons on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @02:58PM (#15656366)
They're only thus bound if increasing stakeholder returns over time is an explicit condition of their contract (which I imagine is the case for executive contracts in many if not most public companies, though I don't know - can anyone confirm?)

But there's nothing in the (US, at least) legal definition of a fiduciary that proscribes increasing share holder profits by any means necessary. That's simply a convenient myth spread to normalize cutthroat, profit-seeking behavior at all levels of business.