News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by westoncb on Monday November 06, 2017 @11:51PM (#15641150)
> The premise that subjectivity exists is not consistent with everything else we know without introducing additional structure to the universe that has no purpose but to stroke our egos.

We must be using different definitions of subjectivity. I'm just referring to whatever one experiences at some point in time. Do you experience anything? Then you have subjectivity.

Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by naasking on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:23AM (#15641231)
> We must be using different definitions of subjectivity. I'm just referring to whatever one experiences at some point in time. Do you experience anything? Then you have subjectivity.

We are, because an ontology that takes subjectivity as primitive/irreducible is different than an ontology that reduces apparent subjectivity via third-party objective facts. You subscribe to the former, I subscribe to the latter. It is precisely this distinction that differentiates materialists and dualists in the philosophy of mind.

Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by placebo on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @01:38AM (#15641461)
I don't subscribe to either (and I'd venture to say neither does westoncb). My view is that both are flawed interpretations of reality. Both dualists and materialists assume "objects" to have some sort of independent existence and the argument between them is that the former claims there is something else that also exists while the latter claims nothing else exists. However ask yourself, what sort of existence test can any object (or concept for that matter) pass without the subjective knowing of it? The moment an ontology presumes either objects or subjects as the core premise of reality, it is already one step removed from it.
Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by naasking on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @08:29AM (#15643150)
> However ask yourself, what sort of existence test can any object (or concept for that matter) pass without the subjective knowing of it?

This question doesn't yield any insight, because it still leaves us with the question of the nature of subjectivity, a term you use with impunity but without definition!

You seem to be implying that subjectivity and objects must form some sort of recursive relation, but this then already assumes subjectivity is irreducible and the question at hand is precisely whether such an elaborate construct is necessary. There's plenty of evidence hinting that we're just special pleading about consciousness's special properties.

Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by placebo on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @10:15AM (#15643977)
I did not mean to imply that subjectivity is irreducible, but rather to say that it a mistaken belief that is the flip side of another mistaken belief (i.e reality is the objects/concepts we use to describe it).

>it still leaves us with the question of the nature of subjectivity, a term you use with impunity but without definition!

I didn't try to promote or define subjectivity, I challenged you to define an object without making any references to something subjective (as this is the ontology you said you subscribe to). What I was getting at is that you'll be hard pressed to present any object that is not a concept created by a subject. Mind you, I'm not saying objects and subjects are real, but that they are co-created by the mind and as such are equally unreal as far as representing what actually is.

Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by naasking on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @11:20AM (#15644629)
> I didn't try to promote or define subjectivity, I challenged you to define an object without making any references to something subjective

I can easily posit an ontology that references no subjects. Just because I formulated said ontology from sense perception doesn't entail that it references subjective concepts.

> Mind you, I'm not saying objects and subjects are real, but that they are co-created by the mind and as such are equally unreal as far as representing what actually is.

Except as per Moore, this sort of skepticism necessarily presupposes the very knowledge that it attempts to undermine, and therefore it contradicts itself and is literally false.

Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by placebo on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @04:51PM (#15647996)
>Just because I formulated said ontology from sense perception doesn't entail that it references subjective concepts.

My point is that calling it sense perception will not make the subjective pre-conceptual experience of it go away. I'm not advocating a ghost in the machine here, but trying to show that neither the ghost nor the machine can survive as primitives when put under deep scrutiny, but I first need to demonstrate how neither can independently exist as a valid concept.

>this sort of skepticism necessarily presupposes the very knowledge that it attempts to undermine, and therefore it contradicts itself and is literally false.

Not sure I follow how this relates to the quoted sentence, but the problem with any explanation (physical or philosophical) is that it is always limited to discussing concepts and relationships between them and can never break the boundaries of what can be grasped by thought (this explanation not excluded). My attempt is to show that thought (and thus any object derived from it) is not the pristine reality, but something that comes after reality is processed. At most, thought can point in the right direction (e.g, understand it's own limitations).

Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by westoncb on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @03:27AM (#15641776)
I'm not talking about an ontology--that concept presupposes too much already. What I'm talking about is more basic: if someone blows in your ear, do you experience anything? Whatever it is that you experience is what I mean by subjectivity. If you do not experience anything, then this universe is a much weirder place than I already thought:)
Re:Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe by naasking on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @08:21AM (#15643096)
> What I'm talking about is more basic: if someone blows in your ear, do you experience anything? Whatever it is that you experience is what I mean by subjectivity.

You're evading the issue. You initially claimed that there is nothing to prove about subjectivity. This is patently false.

The subjectivity you apparently experience by observation, if taken at face value as you initially suggested, ie. "there is nothing to prove", is logically irreducible to third-party objective facts.

And yet, third-party objective facts are the best explanation we have for everything else.

Therefore, you do have something to prove regarding subjective experience, contra your original claim.