News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by untog on Monday November 06, 2017 @11:48AM (#15636716)
"Progressive Web App" is branding. I think, as a developer, you can feel free to ignore the term entirely and instead focus on the Service Worker API, Notifications API, Push, etc. etc.

However, when you're talking to a product manager or some other higher-up that doesn't have the same level of technical insight, this bundle of technologies becomes very time-consuming to explain. That's when you break out "Progressive Web App" - a web site that progressively becomes more like an app the more people use it.

Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by matt4077 on Monday November 06, 2017 @11:59AM (#15636806)
> a web site, that progressively becomes more like an app the more people use it.

I like how you've given the best definition in this thread, and IMHO shown that it's a concept that goes beyond this or that API, right after giving us the its-marketing-for-nontechnical-idiots spiel.

Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by untog on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:30PM (#15637052)
Heh, I just think "PWAs" are like the famous definition of obscenity - you know it when you see it. But that doesn't translate very well (or, at all) to actual technical requirements, so we talk about specific APIs at appropriate points.

And I wouldn't say the non-technical folks are idiots! They know a lot of stuff I don't, you just need to nail the overlap in what we both know. And given how difficult it is to explain the Service Worker API to even a skilled developer, best to take a pass.

Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by sillysaurus3 on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:35PM (#15637087)
What are some examples of progressive web apps?
Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by untog on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:37PM (#15637104)
mobile.twitter.com is one that comes to mind - it uses push notifications, lets you add to your home screen and caches at least some stuff offline, though I don't know how much.
Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by evv on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:17PM (#15637468)
Another fun thing about mobile.twitter.com: it is built using react-native-web, so it uses <View /> and <Text /> instead of <div /> and <span />. In theory it could share code with a React Native app.

That would meet the true definition of a PWA in my mind. Ideally, a PWA could utilize everything the platform has to offer by running as a native app, but can also run in the browser for an install-free experience.

Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by sillysaurus3 on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:50PM (#15637202)
If it's hard to think of examples, I'm skeptical that PWA means anything.
Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by untog on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:55PM (#15637251)
...I just gave an example?
Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by sillysaurus3 on Monday November 06, 2017 @01:16PM (#15637465)
All I meant was, if someone asks "What's a desktop app?" or "What's an iOS app?" or "What's a website?" you can rattle off 100 examples without breaking a sweat.

"What's happiness?" on the other hand is subjective. You could describe things that make you happy, but it wouldn't make sense to point to a banana and say "That's happiness." And if you ask "Am I happy?" the answer probably isn't boolean.

"What's a PWA?" seems to fall into the latter category. If so, then we're treading into philosophy territory, which has claimed countless victims over millennia. You can spend a lifetime trying to define love, but at the end of it, you probably won't produce work that can be built on and extended, the way scientific papers can.

It's notoriously difficult to pin down philosophical concepts into discrete buckets of meaning. We have to operate at the resolution of words. They break if you push them too far.

I think it's important to distinguish these two domains. If we can't effortlessly point to dozens of examples of PWAs, it might be better to reject the notion that PWAs can be defined at all.

Re:What the Heck Is a “Progressive Web App”? Seriously by cat199 on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:52PM (#15637218)
so, like, it's like a WAP portal site?

hmm..