News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WikiLeaks Posts Mysterious ‘Insurance’ File by philwelch on Saturday July 31, 2010 @02:37AM (#1563337)
"How can you have a democracy that includes censorship?"

If it wasn't for censorship, democracy wouldn't have survived the 20th century. There are concrete, non-hypothetical secrets democratic states did keep during the 20th century which safeguarded their continued existence and the reestablishment of democracy throughout much of the world.

Everything you say can and has been applied to every power of the state--the power to make war, the power to collect taxes, the power to enforce law, you name it. Each of these powers has been abused. Each of these powers--including the power to keep secrets--needs to be restricted and kept in check, but not abolished. That way lies anarchy, a fundamentally untested system when applied conscientiously to a modern society and a violent nightmare when applied haphazardly anywhere we've observed it in settled societies.[1]

"A more open society is a more equal society, and where there are fewer power imbalances you will get fewer abuses of power. For sake of clarity, I am not including private information; medical records, etc, unless there is good justification."

Privacy and secrecy are two names for the same thing.

[1] Whether hunter-gatherer societies were fundamentally anarchic is an interesting but, in this context, irrelevant anthropological question.

Re:WikiLeaks Posts Mysterious ‘Insurance’ File by _politicalist on Saturday July 31, 2010 @06:00AM (#1563510)
Well, groups like Wikileaks aren't wanting to apply anarchist ideals haphazardly; but rather in a reasoned way to help achieve a more bottom-up democratic world, which of course requires a better-informed populace. Among other things.

For example, Wikileaks did try to work with the White House to remove names of innocents. (I cited it elsewhere on this thread; you can read how they went about it.)

Each of the state powers you mention can be used for helpful things, but usually aren't. Take for example law enforcement. Any society will need some measure of protection from sociopaths taking over. However, the US goes wild with it, using it to achieve by far the world's hugest incarceration rate!

And war requires the highest bar of justification. Needless to say, the US government doesn't come close to meeting it, illusions aside.

Re:WikiLeaks Posts Mysterious ‘Insurance’ File by maika on Saturday July 31, 2010 @03:18AM (#1563385)
> censorship

A state should not have the power to veto any information under the pretence of national security. There is no accountability. What I am really advocating is the abolishment of secret secrets, or any secrets that govern public policy, government decisions/workings/connections/longevity, and that all secrets should be made available to the records of history after they go beyond their limited window of opportunity. Hopefully, in time to counter abuses of power while they are still relevant.

> Privacy and secrecy are two names for the same thing.

By private, in the previous context I am referring to the individual.

> Violent nightmare

Examples would be appreciated. I don't understand what this idea of all information being immediately and universally available and the necessary decent into a dystopian nightmare, is based on.

Re:WikiLeaks Posts Mysterious ‘Insurance’ File by okaramian on Saturday July 31, 2010 @01:47PM (#1564030)
Your argument hinges on the fact that we currently live in a Democracy/Republic, which is highly debatable.