News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook and Google Are Actually Net States. And They Rul... by dragonwriter on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:37PM (#15631420)
No, they aren't, and no, they don't. Evidence: Facebook and Google cannot summon actual governments with compulsory process and subject them to inquiry, OTOH, the reverse can and does occur.

The EU doesn't submit to decisions of Google regulators, the reverse can and does happen.

Facebook and Google are multinational corporations with considerable influence, and moreover through which other (including state) actors exert considerable influence. But they aren't anything like states, and they don't do anything like ruling the world.

Also, the source headline doesbt mention Facebook and Google, and both the HN and source headline are clickbait because the actual article doesn't support the conclusion that what it identifies as “net states” rule the world. It mostly argues that they are a new significant kind of actor, by doesn't really provide a meaningful differentiation between them and international non-state actors of the past, nor a meaningful way in which Anonymous and Google are similar to each other. They've invented a nonsense category, attributed false attributes to it in the article, and overstated even that in the headline.

Re:Facebook and Google Are Actually Net States. And They Rul... by yeukhon on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:00PM (#15631531)
This article argues how many people’s lives are now depending on and living in these virtual online platforms such that we are forming a society there.

It doesn’t rule the world in the same sense as a government on earth. But every move FB and Google make can impact millions’ lives. They don’t invade your home and arrest you, but they can shut down your account. Google can disable your entire Google Account and then you lose years worth of data (this happened recently a few months ago).

Instead of marching on the street to protest, users are now sharing stories and their opinions through hashtags and sharing posts with their friends. They own your data now. They own your lives. They learn enough about you they can lure you into buying products. Instead of shaming another human being with a physical sign like Da Zi Bao (Big-character poster in the 50’s in China), we can gang up on an individual in the comment section. Keyboard warrior, huh? Their powerful algorithms can regulate and determine what we get to see and when we get to see. So many people are “being educated” on the Internet; there are the good stuff like Cousera and edX, and there are fake news outlets). We are grooming a whole new society in the cloud. Instead of taxing your money on a regular basis, they tax your time and then gets revenue back every time you are online and whenever you shop. Instead of sightseeing a new building, people are excited about new features rolling out.

How are the above not evidence of forming a new kind of civilization? Every organization is itself a “government”. Someone at the top is making decisions for you.

Re:Facebook and Google Are Actually Net States. And They Rul... by jasode on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:58PM (#15631521)
>, and they don't do anything like ruling the world. [...]

I guess people interpret it differently. Whenever I see the phrase "rule the world", it's just a common rhetorical device and not necessarily clickbait. E.g. it's common to see headlines like "the US dollar rules the world" or "Hollywood rules the world".

I don't think we have to take that phrase so literally since we know in the back of our minds that nothing really rules the whole world.

I do see that the "net state" label bothers many readers so she probably should have coined another neologism.