News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by crindy on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:32AM (#15630110)
This seems like a silly way to think about FaceID. You’d need 1000+ people to all try their faces on each other’s 1000+ phones to get the 50% chance of unlocking. That’s not the scenario biometric authentication is built for, which is why the phone would require a password after 5 failed attempts.
Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by mjevans on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:42AM (#15630169)
The problem with that is the ease with which anyone can compare their input to the 'key'; externally.

You could very quickly rule out 95% of the field with little effort, and people already do things like say "you look so much like X": we have a short list of collisions already.

Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by katastic on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:08PM (#15630307)
Exactly. I'm more worried about if someone can make a mask of someone's face (or even a print out) and get it to work.

But at least it's not like people have pictures of their faces plastered across every social network...

... crap.

Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by gnicholas on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:36PM (#15630505)
As others have said, those who have tried masks haven't worked. But I wonder if normal masks have different heat signatures than real faces, which an IR array can detect. It's possible that something as simple as standard mask + heat would fool the system. Hopefully not!
Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by zwily on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:31PM (#15630462)
Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by mikeash on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:24PM (#15630400)
Apple specifically mentioned testing with high-end masks, and there have been videos made about people attempting it. It doesn’t work.
Re:Using Face ID to unlock brother’s iPhone X after entering... by ballenf on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:31PM (#15631390)
I agree and it wasn't the intent of the question. More of a purely academic way of putting "one in a million" into more human terms. And it didn't work, since I can't picture a room of 1250 people doing this, like you rightly point out.

But I also don't think the "brother who already knows the phone PIN code" a real world attack vector of concern to most people. I get that it could be an issue in narrow situations: you share your pin code, lookalike sibling uses it to "train" your phone; you change passcode not realizing that phone will still unlock for now-untrusted sibling.

Even in that scenario, I would bet that after a few days of normal usage by the phone's rightful owner alone the attack wouldn't work anymore. But, it's too soon to know.