News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook and Google Are Actually Net States. And They Rul... by danarmak on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:18AM (#15629768)
Facebook can in fact do most of the things you mention.

Their 'taxing' of netizens takes several forms, mainly displaying ads and collecting and selling information about them. Both of these are profitable to Facebook (or they wouldn't do them), and injurious to users (in lost privacy and attention). Facebook can choose how much of it they do; they balance taxation (profits) with user retention (emigration).

Facebook have a monopoly on many kinds of force on their platform. They and only they can remove or block content and ban accounts. And unlike other states, there are no courts, no constitution, and no way for rebels to gain these powers for themselves by force.

The question of granting netizenship is less important, because Facebook encourages immigration: they'd love all the world to be their netizens! But they can exile people they don't like, or block them from joining.

Facebook also have partial control of the presses in their country and of the commerce at its borders (in- and out-going links).

Re:Facebook and Google Are Actually Net States. And They Rul... by gwright on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:15PM (#15630724)
There may be an analogy here but I think you are just introducing confusion by trying to equate ad revenues with "taxes" and customer churn with "emigration".

Facebook's business practices aren't a "monopoly" in any usual sense of the word and so once again it is just making it difficult to discuss the associated concerns/problems by expanding the meaning of "monopoly".