News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by brudgers on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:02AM (#15629402)
An MIT professor can be naive. A history major learns how to read and analyze documents...and how to write. An art major learns how to create art. An even more significant difference between these and many contemporary STEM subjects is that an undergraduate is expected to know how to create original work...there's no copying art homework especially not in an advanced class.

These days I think that the creative element of programming is why software is eating the world at the pace it is. Undergrads can look at each other's code and say Wow! while one titration is fungible with every other.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by HarryHirsch on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:26AM (#15629523)
These days I think that the creative element of programming is why software is eating the world at the pace it is. Undergrads can look at each other's code and say Wow! while one titration is fungible with every other

That's simply not true. The reason that software is eating the world is that the rate on investment return is so much higher. Every time I read a publication from Phil Baran's group I have to pause several times to think it through, it's very deep, very subtle. Website is here, btw: http://openflask.blogspot.com/

It's actually worrying that computing has overtaken science and engineering. Back then, Arnold Beckman made a fortune in scientific instruments and enabled the world to do better science. Nowadays, Google and Facebook sit on huge corpora of natural language texts, and the only thing they do is build better AI for better targeting of ads.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by brudgers on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:58AM (#15629671)
It is entirely true that I think that, these days.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by HarryHirsch on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:04AM (#15629702)
Don't do that. That notion does not conform to observable reality.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by brudgers on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:39AM (#15629853)
One might find familiarity with Hume useful here.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by analog31 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:38AM (#15629847)
These days I think that the creative element of programming is why software is eating the world at the pace it is. Undergrads can look at each other's code and say Wow! while one titration is fungible with every other.

Seeing past this level of understanding is an attrition gate in any subject. What I mean is, the students who got past freshman chemistry to become good chemists are the ones who saw the creative element in chemistry.

Those same students may have taken the programming course and seen different codes as fungible with one another. Or in math, proofs, or in English, essays. I know people who came away from the freshman programming course, with the conclusion that "it's all just memorization." Clearly it means they didn't get it, but it also means it's a widespread impression.

As for chemistry, for reasons we don't know, part of developing creativity as a chemist is to get what they call "hands," which means being able to take care of yourself in the lab without wreaking havoc on everything. You need to have a sense of what can and can't be done in a practical process, in order to see your way through a difficult project.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by brudgers on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:49AM (#15629897)
The 'good' chemists I know eventually wound up at places like Coca-Cola making sugar water after a post-doc or teaching titration...after a post doc.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by analog31 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:57AM (#15629935)
Every field has its own sugar water, and its own titration.

Advertising and GUI design are the sugar water of computer science.

The "coding interview" tells me that at least some aspect of programming is akin to titration.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by michaelscott on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:13AM (#15630008)
I could give GUI design a tenuous connection if pressed, but what on Earth does advertising have to do with computer science?
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by analog31 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:15AM (#15630023)
As I understand things, it's possibly the biggest employer of people with computer science degrees, as well as the biggest revenue driver for the software industry.

But perhaps to generalize, the relationship between "look at how creative this discipline is" and "look at what people actually do with it in the real world" is an issue facing every academic field.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by michaelscott on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:54AM (#15630234)
Perhaps this is a local thing; almost no one in advertising where I'm from comes out of university computer science.

Agreed on the generalisation though. I'd even wager that the "creativity of this discipline" idea is what is attracting new students to fields that aren't too viable after graduation.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by analog31 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:14PM (#15630341)
I think you've raised a good point. I appreciate that every discipline wants to present itself in the best possible light. Claiming to be "creative" is one way. As a math major, I certainly felt that I was more creative than those students in other fields. Abandoning that idea is a benefit of old age. ;-) And every discipline also claims "there will be a worker shortage in our field soon" and "what we really teach is critical thinking."
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by chrisseaton on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:24PM (#15631690)
> almost no one in advertising where I'm from comes out of university computer science

Do you not know anyone working at companies like Google? They have tons and tons of computer scientists working on serving the most applicable adverts as efficiently as possible to as many people as possible.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by brudgers on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:27PM (#15630430)
Google hires a lot of computer scientists. Advertising is it's core business.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by mcguire on Sunday November 05, 2017 @06:02PM (#15632292)
Facebook, as well. Along with all the other ad-supported businesses.