News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet Association Endorses Internet Censorship Bill by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:47AM (#15628196)
> They want to have it both ways

Censorship is one party telling everyone else what they can and can't see.

Prohibiting content is censorship -- it's telling people what they can't see.

Prohibiting filtering is also censorship -- it's telling people they have to see your thing in place of the thing they want.

Filtering is inherently a weighing of false positives against false negatives.

If you require filtering then the false negative rate has to be low/zero, so the false positive rate goes through the roof. No Nazis but also no Republicans or Democrats.

If you prohibit filtering then the false positive rate has to be low/zero, so the false negative rate goes through the roof. Everyone is deluged by spam and malware.

Section 230 doesn't apply to copyright and look at the mess that has been -- worst of both worlds. Copyright infringement is still prolific but people use fraudulent copyright takedowns for things they don't own left and right, and the platforms execute them because they have minimal incentive to question anything.

What you really want is the middle ground where platforms have to compete with each other for users, so they can ban things everyone hates (spam) but lose users if they ban things those people are legitimately interested in (e.g. minority political opinions).

The problem isn't Section 230, it's the lack of competition which gives the major platforms too much power when they decide to censor something. It has to be the marketplace of ideas, not the monopoly of ideas.

Re:Internet Association Endorses Internet Censorship Bill by nnfy on Sunday November 05, 2017 @05:15AM (#15628860)
>Prohibiting filtering is also censorship -- it's telling people they have to see your thing in place of the thing they want.

This reads like a paragraph straight out of 1984. No one is forcing people to view anything by prohibiting filtering. It simply is making certain available on the platform.

Now I suppose one could argue that filtering is a form of speech, but thats still reaching I think.

Re:Internet Association Endorses Internet Censorship Bill by sgift on Sunday November 05, 2017 @05:41AM (#15628909)
In 1984 you had the Telescreen in every house. You were not allowed to cover it up and it was used to broadcast propaganda into peoples homes without any filtering (plus it was a surveillance device, but that's besides the point here).
Re:Internet Association Endorses Internet Censorship Bill by nnfy on Sunday November 05, 2017 @05:54AM (#15628926)
No, the point is that in 1984 you had doublespeak, where people used words in ways that were contradictory to their meaning[0] - in the way that the GP claims that prohibiting filtering is somehow a form of censorship, when censorship is literally a form of filtering.

0.https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublespeak