Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students
by seanmcdirmid on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:48PM
(#15622731)
Having had a tuition waver before, there was absolutely nothing to report (no money paid, no money taxed), it most definitely had no impact on tax filing complexity. What they are proposing is to make tuition wavers a “real thing” rather than something that just existed on paper in a university somewhere, that is bound to make life much more complicated. It will also probably completely restructure graduate education in the USA, since many grad students have free take no classes and rather take 9 credits if “independent research”, which basically means they get to work in a lab.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students
by Fomite on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:10PM
(#15622835)
And it is important that grad students be enrolled in classes, even if they're 9 credits of independent research. Student loans, insurance, etc. depends on maintaining student status.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students
by maxxxxx on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:32PM
(#15622624)
If they also had eliminated the carried interest loophole for hedge fund people and VCs I would actually be on board. I am also a little skeptical of the 25% for pass through entities.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students
by jdavis703 on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:34PM
(#15622635)
The 25% is going to be abused really bad... There's major problems with the bill, but every special interest (retirement savers, home owners, grad students, R&D corporations, etc) coming out for their pet tax exemption is part of the problem.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students
by WalterBright on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:31PM
(#15622616)
In the 80's, Reagan's tax cut deal with Congress was trading reductions in marginal tax rates for elimination of a long set of deductions, predominantly tax shelters. Everyone remembers the former and not the latter :-)
Part of the economic growth after that was surely the shift in investment from tax shelters to much more productive investments.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students
by comicjk on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:53PM
(#15622759)
There are simpler factors to explain the good economic growth 1982-1988: a big drop in inflation (engineered by Fed chair Paul Volcker) and a drop in the price of oil (mainly just luck). There was also a lot of deficit spending. Reforms in the 1981 and 1986 tax bills may have been helpful on the margin, but they're small compared to economic fundamentals.
That said, I'd be all in favor of eliminating all these special tax deductions in favor of reducing taxes if it streamlines the federal tax code and prevents tax dodging and cheating. The idea of using taxes as a stick and carrot just leads to abuses (at least the carrot side of things).
Taxes should mainly be used to fund the government, and ensure that things with huge negative externalities (e.g. smoking, environmental pollution, etc) are paid for. Taxes themselves shouldn't be part of a giveaway. If we need to direct funds to a certain part of the economy the government should just do it in a transparent way, such as offering grants to graduate students.