News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub by Waterluvian on Friday November 03, 2017 @04:19PM (#15621948)
My hat off to you. I read your critical analysis of my joke and for a few minutes thought you were serious.
Re:Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub by ATsch on Saturday November 04, 2017 @12:50AM (#15623852)
As someone with a chemistry interest these thoughts mirror mine unironically, so I doubt this comment was a joke.

I think it's a fair reaction to be mildly annoyed when someone uses something within your field without any real understanding what it does.

After all, programmers are one of the first to point fingers and laugh when e.g. movies use random code snippets or wrong jargon. One of those "Periodic Table of X" things is basically the chemist equivalent of Saying "I'll write a GUI in Visual Basic to track the killer".

This website has a different purpose though, as many people note.

Re:Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub by jjjensen90 on Saturday November 04, 2017 @01:14AM (#15623908)
Why do you think they have no real understanding of what the periodic table does? This is a really silly reaction.

If someone made a map of the US with only cities that have repositories named after them highlighted or some such thing would reasonable geographers think, "this is meaningless! They don't even understand what a map is!" (I hope not).

It's something for fun, and not presenting itself any other way... It's not even "abusing" the period table format for some other data (when I saw the link I thought it might be related to languages used on GitHub), it's literally mirroring the names of the elements that are in the real table but linking to projects with the same name...

Sometimes I just don't get some perspectives on HN--if I were a chemist who also knew that naming things in software is hard, it probably would have made me chuckle not furrow my brow.

Edit: missing word

Re:Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub by flashdance on Friday November 03, 2017 @04:45PM (#15622088)
Poe's law is working against me here, what gives away that this person isn't serious?

I think it's cool, by the way.

Re:Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub by westoncb on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:12PM (#15622519)
I'm curious about that, too. I'm betting they are serious and just didn't get that it was a joke. As it stands I'm not quite sure I get the joke either, but it is kind of funny how useless an organization scheme this is since all the repos are unrelated and it's highly unlikely any one person would be looking for multiple element-named projects.

I think it'd be even funnier if the repos it links to weren't even named after elements, but just had names resembling the abbreviations or something. But then again, it would be hard to find some more useless grouping criterion than being named after an element... I wonder if it's actually worse than random :)

Re:Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub by Waterluvian on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:20PM (#15622547)
It's not an organization scheme in any practical sense. It's just a way of looking at all the repos named after elements and seeing which ones are still up for grabs, because naming things is hard so let's pick an element and name it that! But more than that, it's just a personal exercise and publishing something without getting caught up on weeks of perfecting it.