News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by s_kilk on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:25AM (#15618273)
Ok, thought experiment, what is the death-toll of Capitalism in the last century?
Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by amag on Friday November 03, 2017 @10:55AM (#15619619)
This surely is comparing apples and oranges.

When communist death tolls are discussed the meaning are those who are killed when communism is implemented or re-enforced (e.g. The Great Leap). When capitalism is implemented there is no need to shoot communists.

Death tolls from capitalism are due to other factors which may also exist in one form or another in a communist regime (e.g. war).

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by golergka on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:28AM (#15618278)
I'd say it's in negative billions from all the innovation and economic growth.
Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by brbrodude on Friday November 03, 2017 @08:11AM (#15618509)
If so, then we shall deduct from USSR & China a calculated ammount that came from decades and decades of economic growth they had then, no? It's funny how when praising the status quo some people don't see how they get to ideological mumbling REALLY VERY FAST, yet are the same ones who want to accuse others of 'ideology'(as in "I don't have that, my point of view is objective"). I don't judge tho, getting to understand these matters take a lot of time, 'boring knowledge' like history, investigation and reflecting, I think people should spend more time honestly looking into and trying to understand what this is all about, I bet if you did you'd surprise yourself many times over and see how deep this stuff goes. Facebook-facts based stuff just doesn't do it.
Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by abtinf on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:40AM (#15618331)
Zero.

Capitalism is the system of protecting the rights of the individual to engage in the free exchange of goods and services.

The extent of human flourishing is the extent to which human societies adopt capitalism. Even when it is adopted in small degrees, the result is a dramatic uplifting of billions of people out of poverty.

Capitalism is good and we would all be better off if we had more of it.

All of the mass death and destruction of the world is caused by collectivism, from the killing fields of Cambodia to the mixed economy of the United States. Collectivism is the ideology that’s holds that your moral sanction for living comes from the group; only the leaders of that group, whether through a connection to god or the tribe, have access to the true nature of the world, and so are justified in any brutality they see fit.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by ivanbakel on Friday November 03, 2017 @08:00AM (#15618451)
>All of the mass death and destruction of the world is caused by collectivism,... the mixed economy of the United States.

The mixed economy is currently the main system preventing mass starvation due to poverty in the US. Capitalism, from the start of the Dustbowl and the Great Depression until the intervention of the government with the New Deal, failed to prevent death and displacement for hundreds of thousands of people despite a severe overproduction of basically every kind of foodstuff, because it simply didn't make anyone any money to do so.

The free exchange of goods produced under holdover ownership from mercantile and colonial times, including the ability to withhold that exchange of necessities, is a moral evil. It is inadmissible to let people starve because it is not profitable to give them food, but that is what capitalist thought mandates.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by mjburgess on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:59AM (#15618447)
I can't work out if you're trollling or not.

You realise, that "100 million" figure is just taken from the deaths that occurred under Communist regimes, not as a deliberate consequence of their actions.

Also, you're equivocating on Capitalism and Communism with the idea in the former case, and one particular implementation in the latter.

By "Communism" you mean "regimes that called themselves communist". If, more honestly by capitalism you meant, "regimes that called themselves capitalist" then we would start including Vietnam, Iraq, etc. etc. etc.

And you're equivocating on "collectivism" by which you mean the both, say, Mao's agricultural policies and there being groups that have leaders.

Businesses are collectives. Capitalism, as trade between businesses, is a mostly collectivised system.

Humans goals are foundationally composed of all those which follow from their identity: as they conceive themselves as being part of a group, and as they conceive of their identity free of any membership.

This gives rise to nations, businesses, universities, football teams, etc. AND to personal projects, individual enterprise, and so on.

The difference between communism-in-practice and capitalism-in-practice has nothing to do with the existence of groups, but rather the political power structures which surround those groups: all communist regimes were dictatorships.

The difference between capitalism-in-theory and communism-in-theory has, again, nothing to do with the existence of groups -- but what (economic) rights you take to be fundamental.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by executesorder66 on Friday November 03, 2017 @08:13AM (#15618518)
> Capitalism is the system of protecting the rights of the individual to engage in the free exchange of goods and services.

If they can afford it. Capitalism is actually the system of stealing value from your labour in order to make a profit.

> The extent of human flourishing is the extent to which human societies adopt capitalism.

I guess that explains why two of the world superpowers in recent times are/were communist (USSR, China)

> Even when it is adopted in small degrees, the result is a dramatic uplifting of billions of people out of poverty.

That must explain why China is lifting more people out of poverty than any other country.

> Capitalism is good and we would all be better off if we had more of it.

It's better than fuedalism, but I'd rather live in a society focused on helping each other, than in one focused on exploiting others as much as I can to maximize my capital.

> Collectivism is the ideology that’s holds that your moral sanction for living comes from the group; only the leaders of that group, whether through a connection to god or the tribe, have access to the true nature of the world, and so are justified in any brutality they see fit.

If that's what you think it is, then yeah. That's pretty shitty. But don't you think it's better when people work together and help each other, rather than thinking only of themselves? You sound like someone who drank way to much of the Ayn Rand Cool Aid.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by julianmarq on Friday November 03, 2017 @11:30AM (#15619905)
> If they can afford it. Capitalism is actually the system of stealing value from your labour in order to make a profit.

And yet, freelancers or one-employee businesses are also engaging in capitalism. Are those the ones being stolen from or the ones stealing? Socialist ideas are so confusing that I can no longer tell.

> I guess that explains why two of the world superpowers in recent times are/were communist (USSR, China)

And half of them dropped it while the other is not precisely the best place to live in the world, even if it might be the only communist experiment that isn't a complete nightmare.

> That must explain why China is lifting more people out of poverty than any other country.

Wasn't China the place were only five years ago there were thousands starving in sweatshops? And that's assuming that isn't happening anymore, I haven't kept up to date on that.

> It's better than fuedalism, but I'd rather live in a society focused on helping each other, than in one focused on exploiting others as much as I can to maximize my capital.

It's not like you can't live in such a place today, where are you writing this from? I'm assuming China, given that it's the only example of communism you're using.

> But don't you think it's better when people work together and help each other, rather than thinking only of themselves?

Capitalism prevents this how? For that matter, this you're describing here isn't what socialism or communism are about, as history shows.

> You sound like someone who drank way to much of the Ayn Rand Cool Aid.

And you sound like someone who'd greatly regret his/her life choices once you see yourself in a gulag (or a gulag by any other name). Wait, did you think you'd be spared?

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by executesorder66 on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:35AM (#15634098)
Sorry I'm only replying now. The last couple of days were rather busy.

> And yet, freelancers or one-employee businesses are also engaging in capitalism. Are those the ones being stolen from or the ones stealing? Socialist ideas are so confusing that I can no longer tell.

Well since they are not exploiting their own (or anyone else's) laybour for a profit, there isn't a problem with people doing this. I don't understand what you find confusing about this.

> Wasn't China the place were only five years ago there were thousands starving in sweatshops? And that's assuming that isn't happening anymore, I haven't kept up to date on that.

Yeah, that's messed up and needs to be fixed. Remind me how communist ideology is the direct cause of this.

> where are you writing this from? I'm assuming China, given that it's the only example of communism you're using.

I'm from South Africa.

> Capitalism prevents this how?

Because the entire economy is built upon exploiting the working class. Sure capitalism doesn't stop you from giving a hobo some change, but how does that help him in the long run?

> For that matter, this you're describing here isn't what socialism or communism are about, as history shows.

What do you think socialism or communism are about?

> And you sound like someone who'd greatly regret his/her life choices once you see yourself in a gulag (or a gulag by any other name). Wait, did you think you'd be spared?

Why would I be thrown in a gulag? Do you think communism means throwing everyone in a gulag? How would the nation even function? And I find this amusing considering how the USA has the highest percentage of it's population imprisoned, compared to any other nation.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by dragonwriter on Friday November 03, 2017 @11:38AM (#15619977)
> > Capitalism is actually the system of stealing value from your labour in order to make a profit.

> And yet, freelancers or one-employee businesses are also engaging in capitalism.

Those are essentially two different words that happen to be spelled and pronounced the same. The first is a politico-economic system, the second is the act of of entrepreneurship independent of what politico-economic context it occurs in.

That they are both called “capitalism” doesn't actually make them the same thing.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by Crespyl on Friday November 03, 2017 @12:45PM (#15620491)
> the second is the act of of entrepreneurship independent of what politico-economic context it occurs in

On the contrary, entrepreneurship is very much dependent on the context it occurs in.

In a socialist/communist context, my small sewing machine for customized garments is a "means of production" that is subject to seizure by the "The People". In a capitalist context, I am actively encouraged (subject to market conditions) to expand and build up my own small factory/business to meet demand.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by julianmarq on Friday November 03, 2017 @11:55AM (#15620119)
> the second is the act of of entrepreneurship independent of what politico-economic context it occurs in.

Given that it can't occur under socialism or communism, I don't think it is independent of the socio-economic system.

But, that aside, you have a point. However, that aside, I see no reason to believe the other person wasn't talking about both.

Re:Stack Overflow lays off 20% of staff by dragonwriter on Friday November 03, 2017 @12:10PM (#15620243)
> Given that it can't occur under socialism or communism

While the domain may be limited, it has been permitted in some degree in most real-world implementations of socialism or communism (and it was also widely practiced in pre-capitalist systems, like feudalism.)

There's a relationship between the two terms (capitalism-the-economic-system was named “capitalism” by it's critics because it organizes the structure of society around the interests of those who have been most successful in in capitalism in the sense of private endeavors to acquire capital, after all.)