News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Timber Towers Are on the Rise in France by adventured on Thursday November 02, 2017 @01:41AM (#15608105)
> Humans are notoriously bad at planning for the long term

Quite the opposite in fact. Humans are better than any other living things on the planet at planning over extremely long durations in relation to their life expectancy. Few other living things can even plan beyond a very, very short duration to begin with.

We do 20, 50, 100 year business & government agreements.

We build power grids that last decades or a century. We also frequently plot out power supply / generation for our grids that extend over many decades.

We put up buildings that last centuries.

We create water systems that last centuries.

We implement government structures and programs that last decades or centuries by design.

We create places of education, such as universities, that last centuries.

We frequently plant renewable forests that require planning over decades.

We regularly choose careers and life pathways (eg marriage, children) meant to last decades.

When it comes to this planet, we're extraordinary at long-term planning, even though we're also obviously not perfect at it.

Re:Why Timber Towers Are on the Rise in France by ericd on Thursday November 02, 2017 @02:30AM (#15608285)
It's possible to be simultaneously bad at something and still the best. I think the idea that we're bad at planning comes partly from the fact that we fail to meet our expectations very regularly.
Re:Why Timber Towers Are on the Rise in France by tibu on Thursday November 02, 2017 @02:51AM (#15608353)
Still we have less and less rainforests. Maybe some of us are good in planning, but the questions is what's in focus. Money or sustainability. I think nowadays it is still money.
Re:Why Timber Towers Are on the Rise in France by ekianjo on Thursday November 02, 2017 @04:47AM (#15608771)
Can I disagree with some of your statements?

> We put up buildings that last centuries.

Not true anymore, Most modern constructions don't last very long. And this is survivorship bias as well, since most of what remains from previous centuries is just what was strong enough to withstand time. The large majority has disappeared and you just don't see it.

> We implement government structures and programs that last decades or centuries by design.

Look at the political map 100 years ago vs now, nothing lasts for very long. Look at currencies 100 years ago and now, you'd be surprised how much has changed as well. Political systems are by far the most unstable ones of your examples. You'd be lucky to be in a country for you whole lifetime without a drastic political or economic change.

> We frequently plant renewable forests that require planning over decades.

Yet we don't take care very well of ancient forests that were there for hundreds of millenia before us. Look what's happening in South America.

> We regularly choose careers and life pathways (eg marriage, children) meant to last decades.

The rate of divorces, single-parent families in modern times seems to indicate we are pretty bad at making such choices. They are "meant" to last decades but they usually don't.

> When it comes to this planet, we're extraordinary at long-term planning

We have also found ways to completely destroy and pollute our environment in a very short time, while the footprint of other species is much lower than humans overall. Overfishing has emptied fishes from many seas around the world. Numerous species are disappearing as we destroy their habitat. That's certainly not the signs of "species that plan well".

Re:Why Timber Towers Are on the Rise in France by blattimwind on Thursday November 02, 2017 @05:18AM (#15608889)
>> We regularly choose careers and life pathways (eg marriage, children) meant to last decades.

> The rate of divorces, single-parent families in modern times seems to indicate we are pretty bad at making such choices. They are "meant" to last decades but they usually don't.

This is mostly a "don't want to", not a "can't". Being married "only" once in your life (or having children...) is apparently considered boring, old-fashioned and backwards by many.