> The industry is paying five times what universities are paying. Not Fifty percent. Not double. Five times.
Nope, not missing that. You don't think this happened in 1999-2000?
I agree with you that grad students are ruthlessly exploited. I've seen that firsthand. I routinely discourage people from doing a Ph.D. for that reason. And if you're not too far along, taking a terminal master's and leaving for industry is a solid option, especially because this AI bubble won't last forever. But if, like the one student in TFA, you have just one year left, quitting grad school is not a great idea. Now you have, at best, an awkwardly long stretch of grad school on your CV with a master's degree on the end of it, and at worst, no degree at all to show for your pains. At that point, just suck it up and finish the degree.
I do. I'm yet to see people who jumped away from academic CS tracks at the time being upset about their decisions. I do know of dozens degreed people in their late thirties reporting to C students while making quarter of the salary of the same C students.
You can't do that with AI. The amount of material you need to get on top of is really something else, especially if you want to be able to understand the foundations of what you're doing- which stretch back several decades before statistical machine learning, popular as it is today.
Do you know that it was possible to get a PhD in genetic sequencing not a very long time ago from very serious schools? That's right, what today can be done by a random student or a random outsourcing shop in a third world country used to be a PhD worthy specialty.
In 5 years today's ML/AI PhDs would be in the same peculiar position as PhDs of genetic sequencing.
Are you speaking from experience? Because my own experience from my degree and Master's AI courses and lectures is completely different to what you describe. Particularly during my Master's, code was only incidental; the meat and potatoes of each and every lecture was theory.
It depends of course on the quality of the teaching in a given institution, but, for instance, you can find here the lecture notes from Oxford's Deep NLP course:
https://github.com/oxford-cs-deepnlp-2017/lectures
As you will see, it's anything but just code, or lousy such. Of course, that's Oxford, their teaching is world-class- but most AI courses I've found on the internet are similar in scope.
Really, it's pointless trying to teach AI with "just code" - because in AI you can't really code much, unless you understand the theory.
>> In 5 years today's ML/AI PhDs would be in the same peculiar position as PhDs of genetic sequencing.
I think what you're saying is that in 5 years, people knowing Tensor Flow or Torch will be a dime a dozen.
Perhaps- but someone will still need to figure out some way to acquire new knowledge.
Also, it bears repeating that AI is not just statistical machine learning and statistical machine learning itself is not just deep learning. AI is a broad field with communities focused on many different subjects. Just as an example you can find information on, easily, try probabilistic programming.
These days it's really easy to get all the information you need to teach yourself whatever you need to. If you have problems, ask the Internet for help.
And these days, if you want to work on the actual leading edge, it's likely at Google, not at a University.
The information may be online but it's not organised in any way and if you're learning on your own, first you have to figure out what information is relevant to what you want to learn. University offers focus, support and guidance that you don't have when you're on your own.
I think a lot of developers treat machine learning as just another technology they can get good at if they apply themselves to it, like blockchain, non-relational databases, VR etc. In truth, AI is nothing like that. You really need to grok some background knowledge before you can do anything useful with it.
You can sure learn to use the free-access tools available today, like TensorFlow or Keras etc, but, for instance, you're not going to just figure out how to roll your own deep learning framework just by reading a few books you found online- like you could do for, say, a web framework. Nor does it mean that, just because you learned how to use a machine learnign framework, you can discover new knowledge and invent new machine learning algorithms, or optimise existing ones.
Which means- someone else always has to be there to do the hard work for you.
I'd say, that's the reason why it's AI PhD students who are being poached, and not just random devs who declare themselves "passionate about machine learning" on their facebook pages. Because the AI PhDs already have the background the big AI companies are looking for.
More so than junior developers? In my experience, "junior programmer" means you'll do ten times the work for one tenth the salary - and everyone will treat you like an idiot on top of that (because, hey, if you were smart you wouldn't be a junior, amirite?).
I do think the exploitation of grad students is a US phenomenon, btw. And the article is about universities in the UK, where I'm pretty sure the conditions are different.
Still pays more than a grad student.
Because if we're going for absolute money amounts, we might as well all give up on any sort of career in technology and shift our focus to getting some managerial position in a big corporation, somewhere- that's where the money's at.
Now it is possible that you are independently wealthy and it is irrelevant to you, but I can assure you anyone who is not independently wealthy would always trade shit job (A) which pays $K for a shit job (A) that pays $K + several thousand dollars, which is the complain of this article
So certainly not "anyone" would pick the best paying job, without any other consideration. Generally, people in academia are not in it for the money and their main motivator is not money- if it was, they would not be in academia.
I don't know where you get your ideas about academics from but I can tell they're not coming from experience with academics.
Also I'm not sure where you get your ideas about motivation. In my experience, the majority of people will choose work they find fullfiling over work that pays more but is not as interesting. Example: the typical developer prefers to be hands-on with code than become a manager, even if managers make more money than developers (in most companies).
I would argue: what's the tangible difference between someone who has gone through all five years and someone who has gone through "just" four of them?
Plus, i don't think applied research is less important than base research.
The industry is paying five times what universities are paying. Not Fifty percent. Not double. Five times.
Professors/administrators whining about it are pure scum unless they themselves are making one fifth what they would be making in a different university that offered them a job purely because they love this specific college doing the specific research or teaching.
What is really pissing off these professors is that with their worker bees gone they themselves would need to do the work - something they are not quite used to.