News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by james-mcelwain on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @01:17PM (#15594832)
Right, but most of the statically typed code in the world is written in C++, Java, etc. If you're presenting Clojure to your organization, the choice isn't going to be Clojure vs Haskell/Idris, it's going to be Clojure vs Java. The sort of boosters for static typing in this domain are the AbstractSingletonProxyFactoryBean people. I think defenders of static typing have at least some burden to defend "actual existing type systems" rather than immediately falling back to "well, in Haskell..."
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by pkd on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @03:28PM (#15595850)
Even if we assume that your point is true, Hickey wasn't comparing Clojure's type system specifically with only C++/Java. He was making a general point about static vs dynamic typing. He even mentioned Haskell and C++ in the same sentence to make a point about statically typed languages.

When you are comparing the best of dynamic typing, you should compare that with the best of static typing else the competition is lopsided by specification.

And it's not a fallback on "well, in Haskell". It's not like more "hip" languages can't adopt some of the best ideas from Haskell and OCaml to make their type systems better. Modern languages have already started doing this - Rust for example.

It's about learning from research and making the consumer product better. It's a fact that Haskell/OCaml will never be on the top of the TIOBE index, but they can certainly influence those who are.

Making ill-informed (I can only assume ignorance at best here) blanket statements like Hickey did in _this_ particular talk doesn't help the programming language community.

Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by willtim on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @02:26PM (#15595376)
What makes you assume Haskell is somehow more niche than Clojure? I would say it depends on the domain. Haskell is certainly more mature (~30 years) and has a lot more tutorials and literature.
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by james-mcelwain on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @05:54PM (#15596928)
I totally agree that it depends on domain, but I think that's part of the point -- making these comparisons, i.e. Clojure vs Haskell in the abstract aren't particularly interesting, as it seems obvious that no general purpose language is perfectly general for every purpose.
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by ellyagg on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @08:38PM (#15598009)
It runs on the Java runtime and interops seamlessly with Java which are two big factors in its favor.
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by hnbroseph on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @02:32PM (#15595422)
> Haskell is certainly more mature (~30 years) and has a lot more tutorials and literature.

and yet, still, nobody outside the gated community has any idea wtf a monad is. :(

Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by hellofunk on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @02:44PM (#15595526)
I was surprised to see Haskell in widespread use at several large enterprise companies in Singapore.
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by willtim on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @02:59PM (#15595651)
Yes 40+ fulltime Haskell devs in London and Singapore at Standard Chartered, with many other users writing Haskell.
Re:Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure by willtim on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @03:05PM (#15595698)
Many universities outside of the US teach functional programming and Haskell. The community is open, international and a healthy mix between industry and academia.