News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by luckyt on Monday October 30, 2017 @09:33PM (#15590517)
I did some work on a minesweeper solver [1], I'm surprised my work is not mentioned. The best version of their algorithm wins on expert 32.9% of the time, whereas my AI achieves about 50% win rate. My AI uses the connected components decomposition that they did, but also some endgame tactics that significantly improved win rate (that they didn't consider).

[1]: https://luckytoilet.wordpress.com/2012/12/23/2125/

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by leni536 on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @07:03AM (#15592283)
> Each of these 11 configurations should be equally likely to be the actual position.

This is not true. For calculating the odds of a configuration you need to take into account the non-border squares and the number of the remaining mines too.

Example (3 remaining mines):

    1111
    *22*
    xxxx
    xxxx
The * represents the marked mines, 'x' represents the unmarked squares.

There are three border configurations:

    1. mine, empty, empty, mine
    2. empty, mine, empty, empty
    3. empty, empty, mine, empty
But actually the first one is actually is 4 global configurations, as the remaining one mine can be anywhere on the remaining squares. The second and third are 6 and 6 global configurations respectively as the remaining two mines can be anywhere on the remaining 4 squares (4 choose 2).

The probabilities of a border squares to be empty are 3/4, 5/8, 5/8 and 3/4 respectively as opposed to 2/3, 2/3, 2/3 and 2/3 that your rule gives. The probability for a non-border square to be empty is 9/16, slightly more than 1/2.

One can argue that when the number of the remaining unmarked squares is large compared to the border squares this gives little difference. But it's not true, this gives significant differences even when this is the case.

[1] http://nothings.org/games/minesweeper/ "Counting unencountered mines"

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by Someone on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @01:10PM (#15594787)
That assumes those three border configurations are equally likely. In this case, I think that is true, but in general, I don’t think it is true that all possible border configurations are equally likely.

For example, if you add a fifth row of xxxx to your example, ignoring what we know of the third row, the expected number of mines in each row would be one. That would make the first configuration, with two mines, less likely than each of the other two.

Similarly, if, in your example, there are only 2 remaining mines, the first option is less likely, if there are 5 missing mines, the first is more likely, and if there are 6 missing mines, the second and third cannot happen.

Things get even more complicated if one assumes the mines aren’t placed uniformly, for example because the programmer wants to avoid areas of the field completely separated by mines.

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by luckyt on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @10:53AM (#15593640)
That's a fair objection. You can view my rule as a heuristic that's easy to compute and gives good guesses in most situations, rather than calculating the mathematically correct probability.

My AI does actually account for this, but only in the endgame when there are a small number of squares left -- then it considers the global configuration instead of just local. This works out because the endgame is where this problem is the most significant, it's computationally expensive unless there's a small number of squares remaining.

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by leni536 on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @11:51AM (#15594116)
Then I suggest an improved heuristics for mid-game.

You can actually calculate the number of global configurations for each border configuration, they are just (n choose k) type calculations. It's somewhat more sophisticated when there are multiple disjoint border regions.

Alternatively for a mid-game heuristic you can approximate the initial uniform distribution of the fixed amount of mines on the playing field with another distribution: Each square having an independent probability of having a mine or not. This could potentially simplify the calculation but it wouldn't be accurate when there are not so many mines left.

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by Someone on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @12:19PM (#15594374)
”It's somewhat more sophisticated when there are multiple disjoint border regions.”

I don’t see why that would be the case. Can you explain?

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by svalorzen on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @02:26AM (#15591437)
Hey, another question. In your write-up you mention enumerating the possibilities when no deduction is possible, and picking one of the lower ranked cells found like this. However, a couple of improvements come to mind.

First you could weight each possible configuration by the number of mines it contains per square vs the average remaining over the whole board (so a very mine heavy configuration is less likely if not many mines remain).

Another thing you mention is that once you find the counts per square, picking any one of the lower counted ones is the same. This doesn't look true for me. One would also want a click to reveal as much information as possible, so clicking in an area with low density of mines is better. In your example clicking into the middle right 2 next to the three ones would likely reveal more info than clicking on the top right 2.

Did you consider these as possible improvements?

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by luckyt on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @10:57AM (#15593673)
Indeed, those are good ideas for improvements! It's hard to say whether they will improve the AI, as in both cases you're replacing one heuristic with another heuristic. You'd need to implement it and experiment with it -- and I haven't done so for my AI.
Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by ballenf on Monday October 30, 2017 @11:43PM (#15590961)
Thanks!

One question: does your algorithm account for the possibility that a non-border square could have a lower odds of being a mine when you reach the last-resort safest guess approach? It looks like you only consider the odds of mines in the borders, but not that a complete unknown square could have lower odds. You do mention the situation where you know that particular square has no mines, but not where you know the odds are lower than in any of the border squares.

It's pretty rare, but in my minesweeper obsession days I would occasionally see it happen.

Edit: upon further reflection, it's actually pretty common in the early stages, esp. in lower difficulty games. You will occasionally on the first click get a high-ish number and are much better off clicking a non-neighbor as the next guess. You must be doing this or couldn't achieve 50%, I'd guess.

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by luckyt on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @12:24AM (#15591072)
Yes, I do this as an endgame tactic. In some situations, knowledge of the mine counter can help you deduce that a non-border square is empty. (Details in the last part of the article)
Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by taneq on Monday October 30, 2017 @10:35PM (#15590745)
Thanks for the interesting write-up!

You say here yours wins around 50% of the time on expert, whereas your linked article says 50% of the time on advanced - is this a typo, and/or what's your success rate on expert?

Re:Algorithmic Approaches to Playing Minesweeper (2015) by luckyt on Monday October 30, 2017 @10:51PM (#15590792)
Same thing -- 16x30 with 99 mines.