News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by brndnmtthws on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:19PM (#15586909)
25% cash is ludicrous and irresponsible. Cash has historically been a terrible 'investment', especially since most central banks have maintained a policy of creating annual inflation.

Warren Buffett has some interesting things to say about this: https://20somethingfinance.com/warren-buffett-is-moving-100-... and http://www.barrons.com/articles/buffett-bonds-terrible-in-co... for example.

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by snikeris on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:25PM (#15586968)
I think this article may clear some things up for you:

https://portfoliocharts.com/2017/05/12/understanding-cash-wi...

Harry's 25% cash isn't dollar bills, it's treasury bills, which have held up to inflation.

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by SilasX on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:30PM (#15587026)
Or you could apply the deep understanding you gained from the article to untangle the misconception you believe the parent was harboring, rather than ask everyone, on faith, to spend fifteen minutes figuring it out for themselves, when they might not even get the insight you want them to.

>Harry's 25% cash isn't dollar bills, it's treasury bills, which have held up to inflation.

Short-term ones haven't for last ~10 years, especially if it's a taxable account.

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by snikeris on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:41PM (#15587147)
The argument of the OP almost exactly fits this lead in to the article:

> I hear some version of this argument all the time: The opportunity cost for holding cash is too high. It earns virtually nothing, and you’re guaranteed to lose money to inflation. Just get over your fear and buy stocks!

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by SilasX on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:57PM (#15587302)
I get that the article promises to refute what the OP said, but if it really provided a relevant insight, you should be able to summarize the insight so as to contribute to the current discussion and let others know whether they've already heard the argument, or what crucial assumptions it makes, and whether the refutation really gets at the core point of the parent's objection (or is just nitpicking). And save the thousand people 15 minutes of figuring it out.

It would be much more helpful to say something like "having an investment of stable value can decrease the volatility of the returns as you balance in and out during the market ups and downs, and improving the risk-adjusted returns, which back-testing can demonstrate". (I don't know if that's what it said, but that's an example of contributing the insights back to the discussion.)

And if the article really did provide insight, wouldn't it be easy to produce a paragraph like the above?

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by snikeris on Monday October 30, 2017 @02:24PM (#15587568)
I appreciate you schooling me on how to better contribute to the discussion. This was my attempt at what you're discussing (admittedly appended perhaps after your initial comment):

> Harry's 25% cash isn't dollar bills, it's treasury bills, which have held up to inflation.

OP seemed to be under the misconception that cash meant dollar bills under the mattress. The article addresses this in the section beginning "To explain, I think it helps to start with the definition of cash..."

OP seemed to be under the misconception that cash responds poorly to inflation, which the article also addresses.

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by SilasX on Monday October 30, 2017 @02:37PM (#15587692)
If your only point is that "cash" includes short-term T-bills, then

1) What else is the article adding? The fact that it (historically) yields something above inflation was enough to refute the OP's implied claim about negative real returns.

2) That wouldn't address the OP's point that they still have a low RoR for a long-term portfolio.

3) As in my comment it wouldn't refute that T-bills haven't kept up with inflation recently.

If the article's point is about how balancing into/out of a stable investment can improve portfolio return, then that would warrant a summary in your comment.

Sorry if my comments come off as mean. I'm trying to convey why a giant article might not be helpful to resolving the disagreement.

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by snikeris on Monday October 30, 2017 @03:33PM (#15588161)
My points were that cash includes short-term T-bills, and that they have held up to inflation, both points addressed in the article I linked.

> Sorry if my comments come off as mean.

You're not coming off as mean. I can tell you're genuinely trying to improve the discussion here, and you reminded me that when I'm replying to someone, the audience is wider than just that person. Thanks.

Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by pdog on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:27PM (#15587000)
Berkshire Hathaway currently has a $100 billion cash stockpile. There have been multiple times in Mr. Buffett's career when he waited for better investment opportunities by holding cash. Besides, cash isn't so bad. If you roll over short-term Treasury bills, you basically keep up with inflation.
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by swendoog on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:22PM (#15586939)
Possibly holding cash is useful for when you need to quickly capitalize on a drop in the market?
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by tanderson92 on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:26PM (#15586981)
One can do that with treasuries or T-bills which historically have earned a real return. In a crisis one often finds that treasuries are negatively correlated with equities which can be a boon.
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by tome on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:35PM (#15587089)
T-bills are what Harry Browne means by "cash".
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by brndnmtthws on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:27PM (#15586988)
Bonds are better suited for that purpose, however it's still preferred to just hold stocks over the long term. Holding bonds provides stability at the expense of drag.
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by tome on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:34PM (#15587077)
Cash earns interest so it's not as terrible an "investment" as you make out, but its real strength comes from being able to buy into crashes.
Re:Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) by loeg on Monday October 30, 2017 @02:01PM (#15587332)
Nothing in TFA mentions 25% cash.