Re:The meaning of AMP
by SquareWheel on Monday October 30, 2017 @01:44PM
(#15587183)
I'd say the advantage of share buttons using the proper canonical tag is it strips away user-customizations, tracking information (utms), and other info.
So for instance if a user clicks the "comments" link on a blog post, it won't then skip the article when people view it.
Though I can also see downsides. For instance you might click on a specific version of a product on an ecommerce site. If you share it and say "I love this version!", that information could be lost in the process.
The normal behavior of "share sends the precise page I am currently viewing" has the advantage that you know what you're sending, whereas trusting the website's rel="canonical" opens up some potential confusion. (And, I guess, sneaky attack vectors, though someone who wanted to exploit that could do so easily enough via JS redirects on non-referer visits anyway.)
The Google Amp people certainly think that's the right way to do it, as we can see here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15085159
EDIT: Actually, I'm seeing some claims that iOS Safari is just generically doing share-is-rel-canonical now. I haven't tested it personally, but...