News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solar power is now cheaper than nuclear by rbanffy on Thursday July 29, 2010 @02:12PM (#1558553)
dmfdmf's point is that it takes more energy to make a solar cell than it will ever produce during its lifetime.

I am not sure his numbers are current (he made the disclaimer), but it has nothing to do with energy pricing.

My worry is not whether photo-voltaic is net-positive, but whether the production actually reduces pollution. For what I know, they are very close cousins of computer chips and those factories were not particularly "green".

Re:Solar power is now cheaper than nuclear by Retric on Thursday July 29, 2010 @02:44PM (#1558726)
Energy is a complex topic, so calculating the actual energy costs to produce something is hard because different forms of energy have different value. EX: heat pumps don't generate energy even though they can output more BTU's than an electric heater.

However, electricity cost to generate other types of energy works as a shortcut to a lot of this stuff. So generally if something costs X$ to manufacture it takes less energy than X$ worth of electricity.

As to being green; PV is not exactly a single technology with a single type of environmental impact. Assuming you recycle the cells, PV can have a very environmentally friendly footprint, but the factory must also take care to avoid a wide range of pollution.

PS: It’s hard to talk about energy without using enthalpy, entropy, and other thermodynamic concepts. If my point is not clear I can try a more detailed explanation.