I kind of liked it better when it was hobbyists and enthusiast sites. The "web as we know it" isn't necessarily a great thing.
Hobbyists and enthusiasts do not scale to ~3 billion people.
Neither do most other things done by hobbyists. I don't understand what you're saying. The only things that are good enough to do are those that scale to 3 billion people?
I am saying, if you want a web by and for hobbyists and enthusiasts, billions of people has to be excluded.
Where do you think new hobbyists come from?
I don't think lack of participation is the same thing as "exclusion". Bird watching is another enthusiast hobby. Anyone can do it. But not everyone wants to.
It seems clear at this point that several billions of people want to use the web, not just hobbyists.
Who says we need a monetization method?
The web existed and was great pre-advertising.
Also, if there is going to be monetization via advertising, why does it have to be a blind auction controlled by an algorithm driven by CPM with a huge cut going to Google?
I wonder what would happen if the major publications collectively decided to switch to impression-based rather than click-based metrics.
Unless you have a viable alternative monetization method?