News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by s_kilk on Monday October 30, 2017 @07:44AM (#15584307)
> ”Our civilization cares about whether Microsoft stock will be priced at $37.70 or $37.75 tomorrow afternoon.”

This is not a good thing. Vastly more effort is being poured into this than is being dedicated to averting climate catastrophe.

In the future, this era will be looked back on as the pinnacle of the grotesque irrationality and chaos of Capitalism, if there's anyone even left to have such thoughts.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by eru on Monday October 30, 2017 @09:09AM (#15584704)
Somewhat ironically, if you want less societal resources to be spend on price discovery, you have to make price discovery easier. Ie unleash the full powers of the market via unlimited short selling, exotic derivatives, elimination of the sub penny rule (https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.htm...) etc. If less effort can discover prices quicker, there will be less money to be made total, and thus in equilibrium those bright PhDs will rather go and help eg Google sell more ads.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by manodocedoceu on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @08:53AM (#15592824)
Im not a believer in the efficient market hypothesis. Remember, it's a hypothesis.

Also, The grand central station analogy is just that, an analogy.

Both of these dangerously oversimplify the phenomenon they try to describe. Modern Markets are unfathomably complex systems.

The Efficient market hypothesis is useful as a tool in reaching approximate, generalized, comprehension (ie: for lays and as a peripheral complement for practictioners), but not at all useful in application (some wonderful historical examples out there, study up!).

The fact is that price and markets are not mechanistic. Price has some seemingly objective measures, but those are actually based on projections of future value.

Price is based on collectively determined projections/belief of future value, sure, but this talk of markets becoming more efficient is moot, as we are seeing that, while reacting faster and in more iterations due to transaction efficiency, those don't help us find a 'better' indexable measure of the future value. Furthermore, transactuon costs have lowered, but it's arguable that the diversity of perspectives governing price have been reduced quite drastically.

1) unquestioning belief in efficient market hypothesis is a classic 'confuse the word-concept rose with the actual rose' fallacy. It doesn't work in making actual decisions.

2) price is a subjective gauge of expected future value. As we arent in the future it's impossible to have a more efficient price, since there is no objectivity with which to match.

3) price finding efficiency ≠ transaction efficiency

4) transaction efficiency has improved concurrently with the hyperstandardization of perspective, method and hypercentralization of participation, which has made price-finding of 'financial markets' much less effective as a universal gauge with any bearing on physical markets composed of commercial transactions with merit to anyone other than speculators in abstract 'markets.'

5. Considering all of the above, your argument that improved transaction efficiency is the same as improved price efficiency, and that faster and cheaper transactions will reduce brain-drain seems about as silly as the 'we don't need to worry about babyloniancivilization-induced mass-extinction because singularity.'

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by eru on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @04:25PM (#15596249)
The term 'efficient market hypothesis' is a bit of a misnomer in the singular. It's actually a bunch of hypothesis that eg differ in strength. The strongest form, that markets knows everything, is probably wrong. The weakest form, that it's hard work to beat those traders at hedge funds and Goldman Sachs with information you got out of the evening news, is almost certainly true. Exactly which strength in the middle applies in the real world is an empirical question and depends eg on the markets under observation.

In any case, https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.htm... makes for some interesting arguments.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by skybrian on Monday October 30, 2017 @11:34AM (#15585759)
Not sure it's necessary? The trend towards index funds will do it.

There's an argument that a lot of money is made by correcting other investor's mistakes. As below-average investors switch to index funds, competition gets tougher among the remainder who are smarter on average.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by eru on Monday October 30, 2017 @05:04PM (#15588877)
Yes, the move towards low cost investing is great, too. Sucks out lots of profitability out of the financial industry.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by Bromskloss on Monday October 30, 2017 @10:57AM (#15585411)
Is it irrational? Unfortunate, perhaps, in a tragedy-of-the-commons sort-of-way (assuming that everyone shares your beliefs and goals), but who is being irrational?
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by mcguire on Monday October 30, 2017 @11:08AM (#15585499)
If you make every decision optimally but still end up driving your car off a cliff, there may be something wrong with you definition of rationality.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by dsacco on Monday October 30, 2017 @12:34PM (#15586407)
That doesn’t seem to be a neutrally presented analogy in good faith to the discussion. You can mount a cogent argument that various financial institutions in our culture are suboptimal for a given metric, and you can further posit that those metrics are what we should be optimizing for to achieve some normative imperative.

But those aren’t arguments you made, and as stated your analogy is so hyperbolic and unsubstantiated it feels like you’re only engaging with the topic to forward an ideological disagreement.

It’s not at all self-evident to me that hyper-efficient price discovery in modern capitalism is comparable to optimizing local maxima until you drive off a cliff. I’m willing to be shown why this is the case, but again, those aren’t the arguments you’ve made.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by Bromskloss on Monday October 30, 2017 @11:53AM (#15585948)
That doesn't seem like an equivalent situation. I'm talking about a tragedy-of-the-commons situation, where an individual has a negligible influence over the climate, and so might rationally go ahead and instead spend his effort on something that he will actually get some benefits from.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by makoConstruct on Monday October 30, 2017 @09:46PM (#15590568)
This is also something Yudkowsky has something interesting to say about

https://arbital.com/p/logical_dt/

Summary: LDT is a decision theory that is able to recognise that the decisions of all agents who implement LDT will be correlated. When it makes a decision it knows that it's making the decision for its entire decision-theoretic equivalence class. If it ever decided to knowingly do a thing that is "individually rational" but collectively disastrous, in cases where the personal cost of the disaster outweighs the personal benefits of defecting, then it would be malfunctioning.

I put quotes around "individually rational" because, in light of LDT, CDT is not really rational. It performs worse. It doesn't win.

And, personally, I don't think the old model of decisionmaking was closer to what humans intuitively consider to be sane, effective decisionmaking, I think we had to be taught to be ruthless parasites who can't keep promises, and I hope we can unlearn that now.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by chriswarbo on Monday October 30, 2017 @12:17PM (#15586200)
Individuals may be acting in their own self-interest, but civilisation is acting irrationally.

One of the roles of government is to impose rules and regulations that steer individual (and corporate) self-interest in directions which are widely agreed to be in the interests of civilisation (like preventing/mitigating climate change) but which would otherwise be ignored or worsened if left to individuals or corporations.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by Bromskloss on Monday October 30, 2017 @12:46PM (#15586534)
> Individuals may be acting in their own self-interest, but civilisation is acting irrationally.

Yes, individuals acting rationally is just the thing. If we look closely enough at a civilisation or other group of people, it does break apart into individuals. The individuals are the ones who ultimately has the capacity to act, and has goals (a utility function) and knowledge to base their acts upon.

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by mcguire on Monday October 30, 2017 @05:37PM (#15589126)
Right, individuals are the point. Local optimization, no matter how well done, may not get you to a global optimum.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by Bromskloss on Monday October 30, 2017 @06:28PM (#15589546)
Are you sure it is a matter of local versus global optima? Isn't it rather that what you refer to as the global optimum isn't the optimum for the individual actors, and that each individual benefits from deviating from it (at the expense of everyone else)?
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by mcguire on Monday October 30, 2017 @09:55PM (#15590602)
This is the tragedy of the commons viewed as an optimization problem. A global optimum provides benefits essentially perpetually, making it more valuable than the local optimums which are arrived at by each actor individually. (It does require extending the time though the actor's descendents.)

Hence the old saw's insistence on "enlightened self interest".

Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by Chris_Jay on Monday October 30, 2017 @12:16PM (#15586198)
Granted, but it would still seem rational for everyone to prioritize aligning our short- and long-term incentives so that this sort of tragedy doesn't become worse than it has to be.
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by V-eHGsd_ on Monday October 30, 2017 @11:33AM (#15585743)
I mean, maybe you're not optimizing for not driving off a cliff :)
Re:Inadequacy and Modesty by gravy on Monday October 30, 2017 @09:38AM (#15584884)
Don't companies participating in hyper-competition only compete for the best products/services/etc. in the eyes of their customers? I mean, companies only get money (investments) if there is promise or results that their product can make money (sales) in a ratio beneficial to the investors. So doesn't everyone win in this case? Not accounting for practices that can arise out of monopolistic tendencies of companies like Amazon or something -- but even then, if competition always exists, isn't the onus on the company to provide the best product for the consumer?