http://www.jefflindsay.com/EducData.shtml
The unions oppose it in spite of the proven educational benefits. They don't seem to have an objection to "whole language", though.
When I was an ed student, the guy who taught the reading-methods class said that direct instruction was absolutely an important part of a whole-language classroom; if you see that kids in your class are having trouble reading words with “th”, then you are doing nothing wrong in the sight of God and Dewey by taking them aside and presenting them with a lesson on “th”. But a teacher in a whole-language class who isn’t paying attention will not realize what kids are getting stuck on and therefore will just assume that everything is going to work out, somehow, eventually. A good teacher in a class that is all phonics phonics phonics, on the other hand, will be aware that a lot of the phonics lessons are wasting everyone’s time on unnecessary drills.
I would argue that any program that lets disadvantaged children excel should automatically be viewed with suspicion.
Is there a good book about these studies though?