Re:Alan Kay on Lisp
by wruza on Saturday October 28, 2017 @12:24AM
(#15573977)
>That this sort of rhetoric is the way almost all programmers and language designers try to find truth and communicate ideas is probably why we ended up all programming in javascript.
It sounds like all the knowledge should be delivered right into someone’s mind in a couple of minutes. It is right there, go and learn it for a week at least.
When I try to directly convince random internet people that e.g. Lua has better async[1] than js due to language primitive that is more abstract and cannot be reimplemented in lower-order primitives, all I hear is usually butwhys and dontneeds, real data on both sides (at best; at worst they claim this code cannot be asynchronous). Instead, folks stick to cumbersome syntactic methods fitting their evolved familiarity. They don’t need anything beyond js, that’s why there is js. And this is one small step torwards less cognitive load and yet we have a friction. Good luck explaining macros, call/cc, evaluation models, etc to them to the point they actually get it en masse.
That said and to be honest, I never mastered lisp skills because it is not actually easy (and I’m not very smart too). You enter the completely new and broad area, where you almost have no clue what you can do. The same would feel a junior entering, say, java after dos basic. But more confusing, because junior has lots of time and is just learning and you’re a professional that “already knows it all” (not really) and has little/no time.
It sounds like all the knowledge should be delivered right into someone’s mind in a couple of minutes. It is right there, go and learn it for a week at least.
When I try to directly convince random internet people that e.g. Lua has better async[1] than js due to language primitive that is more abstract and cannot be reimplemented in lower-order primitives, all I hear is usually butwhys and dontneeds, real data on both sides (at best; at worst they claim this code cannot be asynchronous). Instead, folks stick to cumbersome syntactic methods fitting their evolved familiarity. They don’t need anything beyond js, that’s why there is js. And this is one small step torwards less cognitive load and yet we have a friction. Good luck explaining macros, call/cc, evaluation models, etc to them to the point they actually get it en masse.
That said and to be honest, I never mastered lisp skills because it is not actually easy (and I’m not very smart too). You enter the completely new and broad area, where you almost have no clue what you can do. The same would feel a junior entering, say, java after dos basic. But more confusing, because junior has lots of time and is just learning and you’re a professional that “already knows it all” (not really) and has little/no time.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15472204