LISP macros are formalized in LISP. You don't "go up a level" by using them. You go up a level by going into the human brain and thinking about your code in a way the computer doesn't.
Wow. That's a really interesting way of explaining macros.
I wonder if LISP and LSD encourage similar ways of thinking.
Based on my own experiences with both, I'd say: Yes. Although I'm sure you couldn't prove it mathematically (yet).
Re:Alan Kay on Lisp
by physicsyogi on Friday October 27, 2017 @09:53PM
(#15573578)
I’ve been using Clojure off and on for a few years but skipped learning about macros because I haven’t (yet) needed to write my own. Your comment makes me regret that decision.
In programming (assuming a "computer language" as an analog to "axiomatic system"), there are abstractions that cannot be implemented. You can only implement them by going up a level.
In LISP, you have this "going up a level" ability with macros. The only reason this works for LISP is that the language is written in terms of data LISP can manipulate, meaning you can manipulate code at compile time. Forth has an ability to "go up a level" as well, with a defined way to extend the compiler.