Re:Alan Kay on Lisp
by pmoriarty on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:36PM
(#15571538)
Lisp's popularity came too early. Lisp really needed some relatively powerful machines to take advantage of it, and when it was actually popular most machines were way too weak for it. Now that machines are finally powerful enough to handle it, it's no longer popular, and it has no army of programmers using it as they are using some of the more popular languages like Java or Javascript.
So, yeah, you're unlikely to see that many "killer apps" made with it, as the killer apps of today usually require a lot of programming resources that the Lisp community just doesn't have. What apps Lisp programmers do come up with are mostly not going to be so uniquely Lispish that they couldn't be replicated in another language (see Reddit's rewrite from Lisp to Python[1]).
On the other hand, there's Emacs. That's one killer app whose power arguably hasn't been beaten or replicated elsewhere. But that very much depends on your taste -- and if you agree with that you're probably already a Lisp convert.
Then there's the whole "worse is better" thing. All sorts of inferior technologies have triumphed in the marketplace -- for reasons that usually have little to do with their technical merits. Lisp has itself been a victim of that. It's a vastly superior language to so many more popular ones out there (and many other language designers agree, if the regularity with which Lisp features are pilfered in to other languages is anything to go on), and yet so many programmers are really ignorant of it or have only been exposed to little toy Lisps in their college years, mistakenly thinking that modern Lisps are no better, don't realize how much their own favorite languages owe to Lisp, nor how much more that their language doesn't have that Lisp has to offer.
So, yeah, you're unlikely to see that many "killer apps" made with it, as the killer apps of today usually require a lot of programming resources that the Lisp community just doesn't have. What apps Lisp programmers do come up with are mostly not going to be so uniquely Lispish that they couldn't be replicated in another language (see Reddit's rewrite from Lisp to Python[1]).
On the other hand, there's Emacs. That's one killer app whose power arguably hasn't been beaten or replicated elsewhere. But that very much depends on your taste -- and if you agree with that you're probably already a Lisp convert.
Then there's the whole "worse is better" thing. All sorts of inferior technologies have triumphed in the marketplace -- for reasons that usually have little to do with their technical merits. Lisp has itself been a victim of that. It's a vastly superior language to so many more popular ones out there (and many other language designers agree, if the regularity with which Lisp features are pilfered in to other languages is anything to go on), and yet so many programmers are really ignorant of it or have only been exposed to little toy Lisps in their college years, mistakenly thinking that modern Lisps are no better, don't realize how much their own favorite languages owe to Lisp, nor how much more that their language doesn't have that Lisp has to offer.
[1] - https://web.archive.org/web/20051208055316/http://reddit.com...