http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=712546
http://forum.cyanogenmod.com/topic/3319-stock-apps-that-can-...
http://forum.cyanogenmod.com/topic/1950-galaxy-s-has-been-ro...
I'm very close to switching from an iPhone 3G to the Galaxy S (captivate), so I'm glad to see someone confirming what I thought would be my impression: not so smooth but more functionality. Not sure if I should wait a few months though for an Android 3.0 lineup.
But seriously, a new iPhone costs $199 with 2 year contract. My Galaxy S (Captivate) cost $229 with 2 year contract. You would think that for a higher price than the iPhone -- which is heralded as the end-all-be-all of smartphones, and which doesn't have ANY bloatware whatsoever -- Samsung could afford to not preload an otherwise awesome phone with so much crap.
I think on Verizon the Galaxy S doesn't have as much bloatware.
By the way, if you buy online from AT&T the Captivate costs $150 instead.
IMO the biggest pros (that iPhone lacks):
- Micro SD card storage
- Mount the phone as a USB drive or as a modem (hallelujah, why did it take so long for phones to get this?!)
- Swype (reminds me of T9 on non-smart phones, sweet, although useless in foreign languages)
- Task management, like the OP said
- Sweet AMOLED screen
- Widgets, surprisingly useful
- Mail client allows multiple attachments (why the iPhone doesn't have this is beyond me), that aren't just pictures or videos
- Access to filesystem (yay!)
Some cons (as compared to iPhone): - Apps and the OS sometimes appear to hang when loading or when pressing buttons (it would be nice to add "loading..." screens)
- CRAPWARE - why can't I remove useless AT&T apps I will never use? This is where Apple has a definite edge. Plus they all get loaded during boot, which is a major PITA
- Lack of decent headphones (Samsung Galaxy S specific, I think).
- Power button on the side (just a minor annoyance)
- Android Market not as organized as the App Store.