Re:Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
by smcl on Friday October 27, 2017 @10:51AM
(#15568931)
This is an excellent point I've struggled to put across. Furthermore people act like laws are set in stone and are always objectively Good. "It is illegal" is in some cases not a good argument against something.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
by _Tev on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:35AM
(#15569399)
Laws are usually there for a reason.
You could apply your whole argument to public opinion and referendums - public will change mind a lot, why make such drastic moves based on it?
Re:Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
by smcl on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:19PM
(#15571379)
Usually laws are there for a reason. Then sometimes we have to repeal "slavery is OK" or "black people count for 3/5 of white people" or "women can't vote" laws. Because they're obviously wrong.
Re:Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
by dragonwriter on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:25PM
(#15571443)
There never was a black people count for 3/5 of white people.
It was “states that have slavery get to count 3/5 of their enslaved population when determining the representation the free population gets in Congress (and, hence, also it's voting power in Presidential elections.)”
It's actually worse than black people counting as 3/5 of a white person; its more like slaveholders counting as 1 + (slaves held × 3) / 5 people.
Re:Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
by smcl on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:33PM
(#15571514)
Thanks for clarifying - my knowledge of US history is bad. But the point stands - bad laws exist and "it is the law" does not necessarily mean "it is right"
Re:Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
by _Tev on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:44PM
(#15573156)
Ok that's a good point. I guess I am too spoiled by modern mostly-making-sense laws and annoyed by the neverending "government is bad" rants.
On the other hand, public supported all those "bad" laws at the time ... But yeah, I was wrong, illegality on its own is wrong argument.