Ask HN: Why no individual feedback for rejected YC applications
It takes a lot of time and energy to apply for YC, rejection without feedback hurts. Feedback could be in one line, as simple as : Not good enough team. Feedback would help with lot of decisions.
P.S. I will keep working on my start-up until I run out of fuel.
(
14 comments
| 17 points
| on HN
)
Keep working, and don't put too much value on a rejection. If anything, filling in the application itself is a nice way to think about your startup!
"We're sorry to say we couldn't accept your proposal for funding. Please don't take it personally. The applications we receive get better every funding cycle, and since there's a limit on the number of startups we can interview in person, we had to turn away a lot of genuinely promising groups.
Another reason you shouldn't take this personally is that we know we make lots of mistakes. It's alarming how often the last group to make it over the threshold for interviews ends up being one that we fund. That means there are surely other good groups that fall just below the threshold and that we miss even interviewing.
http://ycombinator.com/whynot.html
We're trying to get better at this, but it's practically certain that groups we rejected will go on to create successful startups. If you do, we'd appreciate it if you'd send us an email telling us about it; we want to learn from our mistakes.
Y Combinator team"
"Do you give feedback on application results? We don't provide feedback on application results. If we did this, we'd spend all our time providing feedback and doing nothing else due to the volume of applications we have to process. Read this for more info about feedback."
From here: https://www.ycombinator.com/faq/#q51
A more detailed explanation here too: http://www.ycombinator.com/whynot/
YC would have to work backwards and figure out what it was that didn't get them to a one. Why is it up to themn to do that work for you? Also, if it was just one thing and they could put their finger on how to fix it... you probably wouldn't be rejected.
"The whole idea, market and the complete team are all crap. Improvement on any of these factors is impossible as everything about your idea, team and execution is shit." I can't imagine that being helpful.
To be honest, your question and example feedback "Not good enough team" give me the image of someone who has no savvy in the field of startups that YC is involved with. That you'd think that that would be a valuable piece of feedback formulated in such a way does not really strike me as something that a founder of a successful startup would think. From what I have read and heard about YC and their projects is that having a good feeling about applications is the nr 1 requirement in the whole founding process, so maybe it was that.
Something as simple as "not good enough team" is very, very difficult to phrase properly. Maybe the team just doesn't feel smart enough. Maybe they have that one guy who they instinctively feel is a douche after meeting thousands like him, but can't explain why they feel that way. Maybe the team is smart but immature. Maybe they realize they could actually be wrong about the whole team and don't want to give false feedback.