News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Startup” asks internship applicant to build their app be... by reikonomusha on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:06AM (#15559477)
This presupposes there are actually issues with some of the aforementioned examples. The ultimate determiners of success are on the side of the company, not the applicant. A successful interview process is one that leads to a successful candidate, and really nothing else.

(N.B., The linked Reddit post is indicative of abuse, so I’m not talking about that.)

A lot of SW engineers complain after an interview process, especially a rejection, because of some “if only”-hypothetical. “If only they tested my real skills and not whiteboards. If only they saw that I’m a hard worker at work and I just don’t have time for side projects. If only they read my resume and know that I don’t need no stinkin’ coding test.” This is a strong aversion to false-negatives. But it generally seems to be in the company’s interest to over-reject according to some “stupid” rules than to over-hire.

I’m not saying that there are no wrong interview styles, but I think there is a supposition and sensitivity of a problem that isn’t being framed correctly—around applicant satisfaction and not company success. I think if more folks ended up being hiring managers, they’d understand the inherent difficulty in the construction of these supposed silver bullet interview styles.

(PS, I say this as someone who has complained very loudly and publicly about mistreatment at Google interviews.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.