News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting Comments?

Perhaps the best way is to ask why do or would you downvote someone?

I know many will probably say they don't care about their down or up votes, or karma more easily called, but it is human nature to see how you have done after putting some effort. I hope that not many of us in here speak - write - without thinking or feeling the righteousness in our opinion. Indeed I think that the reason why we do come here is for each other's opinions, not the facts, hardly the presentation of the facts, or opinions by some external website, but so as to read each others opinion and discussions.

Down voting harms that process. Each and every man has the right to their opinion however stupid it may be. Each and every man too has the right to disagree with such opinion in however reasonable way.

I think I should say again that we come, well I do at least come here for the comments and perspectives of others, that is opinions, and I do not think that down voting senselessly, freely as it may be, without any constrain whatever, is in any way healthy for the community and its participants.

Each opinion is worthy. However much wrong it may be, as long as it is held honestly.

But, perhaps more important is your opinion as to why do you or would you down vote a comment?

( 9 comments | 2 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by andymoe on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @04:58PM (#1555647)
I'm just going to start flagging these down voting questions from now on until they go away. I don't think they add anything to the community. Down vote something for any reason you like. It does not matter overall one bit. Maybe you're having a bad day and you want to take it out on someone. Maybe you find something wrong with their argument or their comment is off topic. Down vote away. I think there is a large enough community here where some version of "the right thing" happens and that is good enough. Same goes for flagging submissions.
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by starkfist on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @04:54PM (#1555624)
I would like to have a new button that bans the user for life if they start a meta discussion about downvoting. It would be cool if this button somehow incorporated the unix "banner" command and piped the phrase "you suck" to the user's instant messenger client repeatedly, until they started to cry.
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by Travis on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @04:50PM (#1555611)
Apologies in advance if this sounds harsh. I think you raise some good points about the HN community and general human feedback mechanisms.

I would vote to keep the meta-chatter on HN to a minimum. Let's focus on our discussions and posts, rather than on making a "community" with rules, regulations, and formal conventions.

If you want a self aware hive mind, reddit is a good place to look. I go there for that; I come to HN to focus entirely on the content.

Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by wglb on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @05:38PM (#1555757)
Flagged. You need to understand the principles on which this site was built.
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by ThomasStratton on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @04:49PM (#1555609)
How can you downvote comments? I only see an upvote arrow.
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by kqr2 on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @04:50PM (#1555613)
From the FAQ:

  Why don't I see down arrows?

  There are no down arrows on submissions.
  They only appear on comments after users reach a certain karma threshold. 
http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by ThomasStratton on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @04:55PM (#1555633)
Thanks. I read the "Welcome" information linked at the top, but didn't find the FAQ until you made me aware of it. Perhaps it should be in a more prominent location for new users?
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @05:08PM (#1555682)
It's a test. see if you can find the secret raid board!
Re:Ask HN: Can We Decide Some Conventions Around Downvoting ... by ThomasStratton on Wednesday July 28, 2010 @05:16PM (#1555709)
news.ycombinator.com/i/ ?