Re:China's Silk Road Illusions
by aclsid on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:34PM
(#15555210)
Other than the historical facts, this article is kind of a weird read. The author seems to be guilty of the same thing he's accusing the Chinese president, namely using history to support their version of how this might play out.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:China's Silk Road Illusions
by thablackbull on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:57PM
(#15555323)
I get a similar impression that the article was a little odd - I think the author seems to be confusing the intent of the message coming from China's leadership.
China is saying, here is a 'story' to help you understand what we're trying to do with the Belt & Road Initiative. In essence, the focus is not on the truth claims of history, but it is a guidepost of what they want to do in the future.
The author on the other-hand seems to be saying, because the history is inaccurate, the corollary is that the Belt & Road initiative will not succeed (which is not a logically consistent argument).
Re:China's Silk Road Illusions
by MichaelMoser123 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @12:24AM
(#15556338)
Also its all a matter of interpretation: you can look at aid to central Asia and Africa as a long term investment. If these regions take off then that would be beneficial to China - it would create markets and natural allies. Creating a win win situation with foreign aid is also a bit novel (so far it was more an attempt get them into neocolonialist dependency, let's see if the Chinese do any better than that)