Re:Ill-Advised C++ Rant, Part 2 (2016)
by stabbles on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:01PM
(#15553605)
It can be useful for debugging and (de)serialization.
Maybe you just want to make an error message from an enum? OK string->enum could get tricky, but enum->string should be straightforward. Please explain why it would be a bad idea.
Re:Ill-Advised C++ Rant, Part 2 (2016)
by alkonaut on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:58PM
(#15553572)
Why is it a bad idea? And if it's a headache, isn't that exactly when the language itself should do it so the developer doesn't have to?
How is it a good idea? Not everyone needs this functionality.
I wonder how much effort might be required to implement a purely opt-in syntax/library for the purpose: something like Ada's Enumeration_IO.
Re:Ill-Advised C++ Rant, Part 2 (2016)
by alkonaut on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @06:16PM
(#15554780)
When you need it the compiler knows you need it. If you have enum Pet { Cat, Dog } and you write
cout<<nameof(Dog)
The compiler could just replace it with the string value at compile time.If you have a dynamic one the compiler could just make an array (or worst case hash table lookup) into a static array created at compile time. It's fairly simple and costs nothing if you don't use it. And it's a lot simpler and more elegant to do through the compiler than through a lib, metaprogramming etc.
And how useful is it? it's at least useful to be part of how most other languages work these days. An enum is should be seen as a list of names and values.
It shouldn't just be limited to be a glorified way of saying
const int Cat = 0;
const int Dog = 1;
Defined like that I'd find it completely unnatural if the symbol names were available at runtime.It has a cost in the size of the object file or executable at least. What if I don't want my data segment being polluted with enum-string-values or, worse, your secret array/hash-table implementation, regardless of how little extra it is?
Something like this ought to be opt-in and explicit.
Re:Ill-Advised C++ Rant, Part 2 (2016)
by alkonaut on Thursday October 26, 2017 @01:29AM
(#15556580)
If you use nameof(Cat) then the string "Cat" is included. If you use nameof(some_pet) then the array ["Cat", "Dog"] is included. It's zero cost for something you don't use and it's exactly the same cost as you would have paid by manually adding this.
Ah, right, I see: the compiler only adds these things if it detects that it's necessary (i.e. there must be at least one use). Can't argue with that.
It's generally a bad idea to do this, and an enormous headache to even attempt. If you want to do this, maybe you don't want to use an enum, because that's not what they are for. Maybe you want a hash map instead?