It's "tearjerker" because it conforms to the definition of tearjerker: "A highly sentimental story, drama, or performance, often intended to arouse heartache or sympathy." [1]
They blame Patreon for their vulnerability and use pity to win an argument. Fact is, they placed all their eggs in one risky basket, and now that basket is gone. They have themselves to blame. There are lots of LGBT people out there who aren't scared for their lives because Patreon discriminates against porn. This doesn't affect the LGBT community, it affects people who bet all their income on producing adult content on the Patreon. Arguing that LGBT are scared for their lives has nothing to do with the actual problem: "we can't make adult content on Patreon anymore, and we have no other income, but we don't want to find a job so please have pity [on the LGBT who are scared for their lives]".
If you're convinced of the importance of ignoring misery one believes to be self-inflicted you should have that argument, though.
What other basket is there? I thought that's the whole point of this letter, that patreon has become their lifeline but now even that is clipped.
People somehow seriously claim that the authors should hide what community they represent, hide the unintended discriminatory effects of the policy changes, and not be so emotional about losing their livelihoods, because it makes them feel uncomfortable to read an emotional appeal in an open letter.
Starting the letter with "We’re writing you today both as adult creators and concerned individuals about free, legal, expression." seems to show the community they represent is "Adult creators and concerned individuals about free, legal, expression".
> hide the unintended discriminatory effects of the policy changes,
They shouldn't hide it, but they should at least show some evidence for it.
> and not be so emotional about losing their livelihoods,
They can be emotional all they want, but it's maybe not the best argument to change a company's policy. If it's masquerading as an argument, then it's emotional blackmail.
> because it makes them feel uncomfortable to read an emotional appeal in an open letter.
I don't mind emotional appeals when they actually make sense.
> "Adult creators and concerned individuals about free, legal, expression"
on patreon are not whom this letter claims they are? If so you are accusing the letter of lying, without any evidence yourself.
What level of evidence would the adult content creators have to bring to the table to satisfy your demands? Representative scientific surveys?
Why will you not take their word for whom they are? Do you somehow know that community better?
Do you not think it prima facie plausible that LGBT, PoC, disabled, etc... are over represented among the most vulnerable of the content creators? (which is the only thing the letter claims)
Because by Jove, that's a damn plausible claim if I've ever heard one.
This is bad for the debate as it tries to shut down all opposition (and I'm not even opposing) and remove all possibility of nuance. This is taking the conversation hostage.
There's saying that this might greatly impact the (especially vulnerable) LGBT+ population, which is a very valid point and should be taken into account
And then, there's tearjerker speech like :
> the most vulnerable among us – disproportionately queer, trans, disabled, people of color and those whose first language is not English – are literally scared for our lives.
> We know people who would be homeless if it wasn’t for making porn on Patreon – and it’s not a small number.
Which just feels like strong-arming the reader into your opinion