News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Promise.prototype.finally by WorldMaker on Monday October 23, 2017 @02:43PM (#15535775)
The catch behavior mirrors try {} catch {} blocks. If you don't need a catch, don't catch, and let it bubble up. Try to keep the things you catch to a bare minimum. The rethrow decision is largely the same for Promises as try {} catch {} blocks, too.

(It's more apparent too in the async/await space where catch is even literally try {} catch {}.)

Re:Promise.prototype.finally by semperdark on Monday October 23, 2017 @03:03PM (#15535995)
Thanks for the reply. I guess my contention as someone just starting to use vanilla promises is that it feels like try/catch isn't the appropriate metaphor to use here.

In my specific case I'm passing a lot of promises to user-made scripts. then/catch seems to make things more brittle. As I said though, I'm new to them.

Re:Promise.prototype.finally by WorldMaker on Monday October 23, 2017 @04:56PM (#15536872)
That's totally fair. There are learning curves involved and sometimes tradeoffs aren't entirely obvious why they were made.

If you get a chance, particularly play with async/await code somewhere. There's a lot of misconception that async/await replaces Promises or is very different from Promises, but the reality is much closer that Promises were a necessary building block for async/await, and some of the trade-offs in Promise design are there to support async/await, based on work that had already been done in other languages.

Maybe if you try to write some of your work as async/await it might give you insights into your architecture and how to make it feel less brittle.