News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solving Problems with MiniZinc by oerpli on Monday October 23, 2017 @05:41AM (#15531904)
I attended a similar course and talked with other students about their solutions and what difficulties they encountered.

From what I've seen I had the impression that MiniZinc had some problems, i.e. it has some unexpected behavior, such as: - reordering constraints changes performance - reordering constraints may change results/feasibility of a problem

For quick prototyping it was nice though.

Re:Solving Problems with MiniZinc by CJefferson on Monday October 23, 2017 @06:03AM (#15531982)
Reordering constraints changing performance is basically impossible to avoid for constraint systems, because we are very bad at predicting which constraints should be considered first -- well, you can always apply some normalisation pass which at least hides the problem from users.

Reording causing changes in feasibility of a problem is a MAJOR bug, and I hoped they reported it. The constraint system I work on (Minion and Essence', a competitor to MiniZinc), has (AFAIK) never had such a bug in any release (they come up occasionally during development, but we have serious tests specially designed to detect that kind of problem).

Re:Solving Problems with MiniZinc by vinchuco on Monday October 23, 2017 @07:30AM (#15532346)
For constraints x>=0 and x=0, switch the order for a performance improvement. This shows solvers have preferences. MZ chooses the solver based on reasons.

MZ seems to work beautifully for simple/modular examples. A professor suggested this one instead (for performance, popularity): http://eclipseclp.org but I can't yet assert if they are comparable or if the statement is accurate.