News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Sunday October 22, 2017 @07:37PM (#15529670)
As I am sure you are aware, there is quite a bit of solid policy discussion on the various nuclear engagement scenarios. For this particular question the idea that if you can respond after a pre-emptive first strike then your enemy will have killed themselves by killing you. Since self preservation is a common thing, the ability to respond post initial strike is essential.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Sunday October 22, 2017 @07:46PM (#15529708)
Missiles do that job just fine.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Monday October 23, 2017 @12:29PM (#15534416)
Seriously, I really do think it is instructive to read the literature on this. Missiles in silos are counter balanced by a premptive strike on the silos, mobile missiles (like the MX) are pre-emptible as well but need more warheads, subs are a good counter threat but are tracked by other subs, and nuclear depth charges are able to clear lots of ocean fairly quickly, bombers with cruise missiles are countered with aircraft.

In all cases there are costs and visibility challenges like you have to open your silo doors before you shoot missiles and over the arctic missiles take 30 minutes to arrive. Bombers in the air can see fighters who might be tailing them but they cant be countered by ground based missiles easily, it literally goes on and on. Measure, counter-measure. Signal, counter signal. Threat, defensive capability.

Literally end of the world as we know it kind of stuff so a lot of time and effort has been invested in understanding it.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Monday October 23, 2017 @12:41PM (#15534512)
I've read a lot about it, and I just don't see the purpose of having bombers on alert these days. It seems like their capabilities are similar to those of ICBMs as an alert force, but worse in every way. They take longer to launch, they're easier to destroy, they're vulnerable for longer, they take longer to arrive, and they are much easier to intercept on the way.

Rather than lecturing me on how I should read more and question less, maybe you could tell me just what advantages bombers have over missiles as at alert force?

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:19PM (#15534853)
Excellent, it is safer to assume people haven't read up on the science and policy behind nuclear deterrence so I generally err on the side of caution. Given that ...

The discussion about putting the bombers back on alert is driven by discussions to not renew New START[1]. As you know the air 'leg' of the nuclear trident counters the simultaneous elimination of the the strategic missile forces and the submarine forces by an adversary. One can estimate the number of warheads necessary for that to occur, and while we stay under the lower limit of that estimate there is surety that the bombers would be superfluous. In the event that New START does not renew (2021) or it is pulled out of early, it takes a while to recover the strategic bomber fleet to full readiness status. Training, people, etc. Some of that can be 'short circuited' by pulling retired (but still trained) individuals back into active duty.

You also know that SAC air bases are located such that they can launch (when they are on alert) in less time than it takes for a submarine launched cruise missile to get there and destroy the base. Those bombers would have the capability to destroy our likely adversary. Further you can launch bombers in DEFCON 2 in anticipation of an action which signals your readiness to fight without committing to wholesale destruction of the planet.

You also know that the threats that stand between the bombers and their targets have counters in place to insure that their mission (the destruction of the adversary that just killed off the US) would likely be successful.

They are, and pretty much always have been, the "revenge" team.

[1] https://www.state.gov/t/avc/newstart/

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Monday October 23, 2017 @02:42PM (#15535766)
What kind of attack could take out ICBMs but would be unable to take out bombers? You say that bombers on alert could launch in less time than it takes for an incoming weapon to destroy the base, but surely the same is true of ICBMs.

Adding bomber bases to the list of targets the enemy must destroy makes their life more difficult, but it seems like the difference would be small. There are, what, half a dozen or so bomber bases you'd have to destroy? One warhead each should do it. My understanding is that ICBM silos are sturdy enough to require a nearly direct hit to destroy them, so you'd need hundreds of warheads to destroy those.

The ability to launch bombers and then change (or cancel) their mission en route is super useful, but that seems separate from the alert role. If you want to put nuclear bombers in the air to put the fear of God into your adversary, you don't need them to be on a five-minute alert (or whatever the actual time will be).

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Monday October 23, 2017 @08:32PM (#15538204)
Since you've read up on this your aware that at the height of the cold war both the Soviet Union and the US possessed enough strategic weapons to obliterate the other country. Further, the premptive use of such weapons would leave the other country unable to respond. That lead to a dangerously unstable system that more than once nearly triggered WWIII.

In an effort to return to sanity both countries agreed to bilateral reductions in strategic arms. The point of which was to reduce the number of warheads on strategic weapons (ICBMs) to make such a pre-emptive strike unlikely to succeed. The next step of moving back from the brink of annihilation was to limit the number of warheads in submarines, bombers and medium range missiles. By the end of the cold war both sides had reduced (and verified) that their respective stocks of nuclear warheads was at a level such that neither side was able to preemptively destroy the other, and entering into a conflict could be more controlled/restrained because there would be significant and incontrovertible evidence of first use while the victim would retain significant response capability. These were perhaps the most important treaties negotiated and executed in the 20th century. And have generally kept the chains on that horrific capability.

If New START is not renewed, and we see a build up in nuclear arms again, then it is possible that we see an adversary (or allied adversaries) who get to the point that they can take out all of the strategic capability of the US. If that is likely to occur, then the first step to combat it is to resurrect the bomber force requiring your adversary to expend more warheads to counter all more potential delivery systems. And the typical hawkish policy is to try to keep the number of delivery systems and warheads ahead of your worst cast threat.

In any event, it is the "wrong direction" we need to go if we wish to avoid killing everyone.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:33PM (#15544011)
So the idea of putting bombers on alert is to make it more difficult for the enemy to carry out a successful preemptive strike. But how? Bombers aren't harder to destroy, and they're clustered together, so the number of additional warheads needed is small. Is it just about requiring the enemy to use 1-2% more warheads in a preemptive strike, or is there something else to it?
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:17PM (#15544886)
To create a context, lets assign some numbers to the variables. No doubt the actual numbers would be classified.

Lets say it takes 8 warheads to reliably disable an ICBM silo and you have 80 silos, so that take 160 war heads for those silos. And lets say it takes 25 warheads to cover all the possible areas a mobile ICBM launcher might be in its various revetments and launch positions. So 185 war heads.

Now you add 15 SAC bases with bombers, each takes say 3 war heads to be sure you get it done, that is another 45 warheads. So now 230 warheads are needed. And you want to be sure and take out norad and the line of early warning radars, so call it 250 war heads total with delivery platforms.

If you limit each side to 125 strategic warheads then in the event of a first strike the adversary has to pick which places they can hit because they don't have enough warheads to take out everything.

So the idea of putting bombers on alert, is to increase the number of places you have to hit in order to eliminate a retaliation capability. That either helps reduce a threat of a preemptive strike (they can't be sure what they can kill) because it increases the number of warheads the adversary needs to insure success. Or it forces them to make more warheads in violation of the treaty which would be caught sooner by the verification tools in place.

Conversely, if your adversary does start increasing their warhead stock pile and you don't reactivate your SAC bases, then you open a window in time where a preemptive strike might be effective and end up with itchy trigger fingers because you think their MIGHT be a preemptive strike coming over the horizon and you don't respond fast enough you never will be able to respond. It is that situation, the so called "launch on warning" scenario with weapons that cannot be recalled, can turn a glitch into a war that destroys the planet.

And no the PRK is not a threat in this way as they don't have the ability to threaten all of the US and materially limit our response.

So the bottom line is that while you certainly could use strategic weapons to destroy SAC bomber bases, the major powers have artificially disabled their ability to do so (without leaving the ability to respond intact) through treaties to insure global stability.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:41PM (#15547005)
It makes sense with those numbers, but those aren’t anything like the real numbers. The real numbers for the US are more like 450 silos and 5 bomber bases. So you’re looking at about 1,350 warheads to take out the silos (assuming three each) and 15 to take out the bombers (again assuming three each).

You could expand the number of bases, but that’s tremendously expensive. It’s far cheaper to build a missile silo than a bomber base and a fleet of bombers to base there.

So in terms of the real numbers, you’re talking about adding around 1-2% to the number of warheads needed for a successful preemptive strike. Again, is that’s all there is to it, or is it something else?

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:46AM (#15547544)
I think I mentioned they were made up numbers, they were illustrative :-) not definitive. The actual numbers are probably in the treaty documents somewhere.

As for the relative cost of building a missile silo or reactivating a SAC base, I'd be interested in how you get to the notion that building a missile base would be less expensive. They were pretty complex facilities, and there are some great videos on youtube about them. An airbase is a bunch of asphalt spread out, a bunker to hold munitions, and a barracks to hold the pilots. I will be the first person to say I have not built (or even participated in building) either kind of facility but when I imagine how I might build one or the other, the fact that the SAC base is all above ground makes me believe that it would be cheaper to build. Could totally be wrong on that of course.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @09:57AM (#15550138)
I understood that the numbers were made up, but this is a case where they need to be accurate, at least in their proportion, for the result to make sense.

As for relative cost, that’s a big reason why ICBMs took on such a prominent role: once the technology was worked out, they were much cheaper than bombers.

It’s hard to find precise numbers, but imprecise ones should suffice. We can look at commercial airports to get an idea of what base construction would cost. An asphalt runway won’t cut it here: you need sturdy concrete runways to hold large planes like this. I believe a B-52 needs even more strength than airliners do, because they have fewer wheels. In any case, the cost of constructing a single new runway at a large commercial airport is many hundreds of millions of dollars, sometimes over a billion. And that’s just the runway, never mind all the other infrastructure you need. Bombers aren’t cheap either. It’s hard to say what a new B-52 would cost, since nobody has built one for a long time, but it’s peobably hundreds of millions each.

An ICBM plus silo is tens of millions. Various sources online list the Minutemen III at a $7 million cost per unit, but that must be nominal dollars decades back. They’d cost quite a bit more now, but tens of millions should be a reasonable estimate. The silo adds significant cost, but it’s ultimately a fairly small construction projects relative to a whole bomber base.

If you can reactivate old bases, that would help a lot, but they probably need substantial refurbishment if they’ve been idle for a long time, and you still need aircraft to base there. And there are only so many old bases to be had.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by ChuckMcM on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:56AM (#15550637)
This has been an interesting conversation but we are clearly talking past each other.

When you say something like : "As for relative cost, that’s a big reason why ICBMs took on such a prominent role: once the technology was worked out, they were much cheaper than bombers." I realize you continue to discuss this as an engineer might, how many lines of code to make a compiler versus an interpreter for example. Your statement is both correct and completely irrelevant in the context of the world we live in with its current treaties.

We are forbidden, by treaty, from making any additional ICBMs, no matter what they cost. As a nation we abide that treaty because we believe that doing so is in the best interests of the existence of the world.

In doesn't seem particularly useful to discuss an alternate world unconstrained by such treaties as the general consensus has been to date that such a world is short lived.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:41PM (#15551655)
I discussed the current state of things as well as hypotheticals, so I don't think we're talking past each other. I am having a damned difficult time getting a straight answer out of you, though. You keep saying that putting bombers on alert is helpful because it makes a preemptive strike more difficult, but have yet to explain how it would do so in any substantial way. When I asked, twice, if it was just a matter of requiring the enemy to use 1-2% more warheads or if it was something else, you didn't answer....

"I[t] doesn't seem particularly useful to discuss an alternate world unconstrained by such treaties...." You literally did just that only a few messages ago! "If New START is not renewed, and we see a build up in nuclear arms again...."

I don't get how bombers are useful either the way things are now or in a post-treaty era. As things stand now, you're only adding maybe a half-dozen targets to a preemptive strike target list which is already 400+ entries long. That doesn't seem significant. In a post-treaty world, it's far cheaper to lengthen the target list by building more ICBMs and silos than by building more bombers and bomber bases. (And we're currently about 200 launchers below our limits under New START, so we could build quite a few more. And bombers and ICBMs are lumped together under the same limit, so you can't use bombers as a way to get around a ceiling on ICBMs.)

I'm open to learning how alert bombers help. And if it's just a matter of using existing resources to expand the enemy's target list by 1-2%, that's fair enough. But so far you just keep telling me that it somehow makes a first strike much harder and that I should do more research.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by cameldrv on Monday October 23, 2017 @06:25PM (#15537439)
Accurate SLBMs, possibly on depressed trajectories. Russia didn't have these in numbers at the end of the cold war, now they do. They have even added GLONASS guidance to their ballistic missiles, which is worrying, because it means that they care about accuracy while GLONASS is still working, i.e. in a counterforce first strike.

Given the time it may take to validate and characterize a launch warning, have the message reach the President, have him make a decision, relay the message through STRATCOM, retarget the missiles (assuming we're still detargeted), and launch, you're talking at least 10-15 minutes from warning to launch. The Russians have missiles that might arrive faster than that. If bombers on the ground are maintained at a high enough level of alert, they can be launched at the very first warning as a precaution, before any irrevocable decision has been made.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:34PM (#15544020)
That makes some sense. Do the numbers work out, though? You could launch bombers on a less certain warning, but they'll take longer to get far enough away to be safe.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by bactrian on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:40PM (#15535124)
Nothing to do with START. It's all about the NK war. Do you also believe the story that they recalled 1000 retired pilots due to shortages in recruiting?

And that this weeks evacuation "drill" was already scheduled?

This is war time preparation.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by foxyv on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:23PM (#15534904)
The only situation I can think of bombers like the B-52 (non deep strike bombers) being practical is against an enemy without serious air defenses. Think Syria, Iran, North Korea, etc... Perhaps as a retaliatory strike against non conventional attacks with WMDs like chemical and nuclear attacks via container ships and terrorism.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by cameldrv on Monday October 23, 2017 @06:27PM (#15537449)
The B-52s don't carry bombs anymore, they carry cruise missiles. They drop off eight of em about 1000 miles from the target and turn around. It is still very questionable whether the AGM-86 is viable penetrating Russian airspace, but at least they have eight times as many targets to deal with.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by bactrian on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:43PM (#15535171)
You blow a hole in the border with the first plane. Then fly the rest through. EMP attacks can also blow a hole.
Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by bactrian on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:35PM (#15535052)
The reason for the 24/7 bombers is to counter any Russian or Chinese aggression during the US attack on North Korea.

We can't risk them thinking we're vulnerable to a preemptive strike for even a day or week.

It's precautionary measure to prevent an escalation to WW3. Hopefully it works out.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by techdragon on Sunday October 22, 2017 @08:29PM (#15529850)
... Unless the silos are attacked by Submarine launched ballistic missiles using depressed trajectories as part of a neutralising/decapitation first strike.

See it's the complicated, many possible options, nature of war planning that makes stuff like this much less black and white.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by eesmith on Monday October 23, 2017 @06:32AM (#15532090)
Whose submarines are you thinking of that could destroy all of the US ground-based missile launch facilities in a first strike?

The war planning based around what you describe assumed the Soviet submarine fleet, yes?

Are you worried about Russia, China ("the Type 094s noisiness would make it difficult for it to reach and maintain patrol areas where it could strike at the contiguous United States"), or India?

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by mikeash on Sunday October 22, 2017 @08:31PM (#15529859)
Bombers could be attacked the same way, and take longer to launch and take less to destroy, so are even more vulnerable.

The threat of a sudden first strike that destroys our weapons on the ground is why we have ballistic missile submarines.

Re:US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert by bactrian on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:44PM (#15535188)
The US can probably see the position of every sub on the planet using magnetic imaging.