News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why are we as a society unable to account for neg... by PaulHoule on Sunday October 22, 2017 @03:18PM (#15528426)
There are many problems

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax

For instance estimates of the "social cost of carbon" vary widely

https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/climatechange/social-c...

one of the most important factors is the "Discount factor" which is highly subjective. (How much do we care about 10 years from now as opposed to 1000 years from now?)

Some people don't like the idea that "rich people" get the right to pollute.

In some cases "paying money" might just legitimize bad behavior. A day care center in Tel Aviv tried charging people money if they picked their kids up late, it was not successful at letting the staff leave home early because some parents decided it was worth paying the fee.

Re:Ask HN: Why are we as a society unable to account for neg... by wnkrshm on Monday October 23, 2017 @08:20AM (#15532579)
If there is a fine involved with a certain behavior, this can commoditize the behavior in a way - it's an extra option that you can buy.

An interesting historical example for this may be the trading of indulgences (pardons for sins) in the late Middle Ages.

When (parts of) the church started to sell indulgences, so that people could pay for spending less time in purgatory for minor sins lead to a veritable explosion of trade with absolution of sin, financing wars, construction projects etc. Minor sinning was suddenly not that serious anymore for the wealthy and the church gained even more economic power.

Indulgences were even sold for dead relatives. Think about your family worrying for the soul of your dead aunt (who had a bad habit of blashpheming) and trying to scrape together what is effectively ransom for an imaginary hostage...

While the rich were relatively fine with the system, the poor were now even discriminated against in the afterlife, since they couldn't just buy their dead realtives or themselves a shorter time in purgatory. In some theologicians' eyes this clashed with dogma and to the public would end up as one factor driving the reformation.

Re:Ask HN: Why are we as a society unable to account for neg... by thinkloop on Sunday October 22, 2017 @04:38PM (#15528803)
I remember that story about the Tell Aviv daycare. It makes for a fun story, but in the end the issue was that they charged too little. They purposely made it a tiny charge so as not to be perceived as adversarial or overly punitive to their customers. Had they properly accounted for the costs of late pickups, it should work out such that everyone is indifferent when it happens.

When negative externalities are properly accounted for, it's less "rich can but right to pollute" and more "if you want to pollute, you have to pay to clean it up too".